TLC – The Teachings of Lord Caitanya—Part 17 VIHE

1991
Vrindavan, India

Giriraj Swami: So yesterday we discussed the definition of bhāva and prema and the symptoms of one in bhāva-bhakti and prema-bhakti. What is the definition of bhāva?

Devotee: When devotional service [Unintelligible]

Giriraj swami: What is the definition of prema?

Devotee: [Unintelligible]

Giriraj Swami: When bhāva becomes intensified, the heart becomes more soft.

Devotee: [Unintelligible]

Giriraj Swami: Yes, all senses of possessiveness are reposed in Krishna. We don’t think any more in terms of my body or my family or my house or anything, and all love and attachment is reposed in Krishna. And we discussed nine characteristics of one in ecstatic love of Krishna, which we should know.

Devotee1: [Unintelligible]

Devotee2: [Unintelligible]

Giriraj Swami: See, anubhāva means any action that follows in the wake of some bhāva. Here someone who is in the stage of bhāva-bhakti, he will manifest these symptoms. In addition, there may be other temporary manifestations like dancing, falling on the floor, rolling. We’ll come to that. Prema has some further developments which are described in Text Forty-two.

TEXT 42

premā krame bāḍi’ haya — sneha, māna, paraṇaya
rāga, anurāga, bhāva, mahābhāva haya        [Madhya-līlā 23.42]

TRANSLATION

“Love of Godhead increases and is manifested as sneha—affection, māna—indignation due to affection, praṇaya – love, rāga—attachment, anurāga—subattachment, bhāva—ecstasy, and mahābhāva—exalted ecstasy.”

COMMENT

So here bhāva doesn’t mean the preliminary stage of love of Godhead, but this is a further development. Without going into the details of the differences between each further development from prema, but the general principle is that one’s attachment for Krishna becomes stronger and the symptom is—special symptom is—that one cannot bear the separation of Krishna, but one wants to experience the direct service of Krishna more and more. Especially rāga—one finds any separation from Krishna to be unbearable, and one desires to serve Krishna more and more. And in anurāga, the desire to experience Krishna more and more is manifested when the devotee does not see Krishna the same at any moment, but at every moment Krishna is revealing newer and newer features to the devotee. Krishna never appears the same, anurāga. And mahā-bhāva, in mahā-bhāva, even one moment separation from Krishna turns into ages and ages. It’s like the gopīs, their prayers to Krishna say that they cannot bear separation from the vision of Krishna even for one moment when their eyelids blink. One moment of separation turns into—it’s like an eternity, even one moment it feels like an eternity.

Devotee: Is this rāga?

Giriraj Swami: It’s related. It means a very deep attachment.

Devotee: [Unintelligible]

Giriraj Swami: All of the residents of Vrindavan have it.

Devotee: [Unintelligible]

Giriraj Swami: No, just like the śānta-bhaktas, they have simple prema. They don’t have sneha, māna, praṇaya, and so on, but in Vrindavan specifically the devotees have rāga and beyond rāga because māna means the anger of love. In Vrindavan, the residents can express the anger of love but not in Vaikuntha.

Devotee: [Unintelligible]

Giriraj Swami: Yeah, that’s the mood of Radharani—mahābhāva, exactly. Very good.

Devotee: [Unintelligible]

Giriraj Swami: This development of prema through sneha, māna, praṇaya, rāga, anurāga, bhāva, mahābhāva is compared to sugarcane seeds, sugarcane plants, sugarcane juice, molasses, crude sugar, refined sugar, sugar candy, and rock candy. Whether the sweetness becomes more refined and more concentrated. Text Forty-four:

TRANSLATION

Just as the taste of sugar increases as it is gradually purified, one should understand when love of Godhead increases from rati, which is compared to the beginning seed, its taste increases.

COMMENT

Here we should know that when the sugarcane seed sprouts into a plant, the seed no longer exists as a seed. When the sugarcane juice is turned into molasses, the sugar cane juice no longer continues to exist as molasses, but in love of Godhead all of the different stages continue to exist. They don’t cease to exist.

Just like ether has the quality of sound, air has the quality of sound and touch, fire has the quality of sound and touch and form, and water adds the quality of taste and keeps the other three, and earth adds the quality of fragrance and keeps the other four, so in the same way as love of Godhead increases to higher and higher states, the ingredients in the lower states remain. Text Forty-five:

TRANSLATION

 “According to the candidate possessing these transcendental qualities, there are five transcendental mellows — neutrality, servitorship, friendship, parental love and conjugal love.”

COMMENT

In the purport, Srila Prabhupada mentions raty-ābhāsa, which is relevant to the discussion of raty or bhāva, but if someone who is not on the platform of uttamā-bhakti comes to the association of pure devotees and imitates the activities of the pure devotees, especially the activities of chanting and hearing, the bhāva within the heart of the pure devotee may reflect on the heart of the other person, and he may have a glimpse of bhāva or raty called raty-ābhāsa and he may exhibit symptoms like the bhāva-bhakta. But one should know that unless one is on a platform of uttamā-bhakti, real bhāva cannot be manifested.

So if someone comes to the association of devotees with the desire for material enjoyment or impersonal liberation and engages in the activities of chanting and hearing in the association of pure devotees, he may have raty-ābhāsa but he cannot have actual raty. Similarly, if some ordinary person comes, not necessarily thinking bhukti or mukti but just curious, and he joins the chanting and hearing, he can manifest real raty. Text Forty-six:

TEXT

ei pañca sthāyī bhāva haya pañca ‘rasa’
ye-rase bhakta ‘sukhī’, kṛṣṇa haya ‘vaśa’

TRANSLATION

“These five transcendental mellows exist permanently. The devotee may be attracted to one of these mellows, and thus he becomes happy. Kṛṣṇa also becomes inclined toward such a devotee and comes under his control.”

COMMENT

So here, the verse mentions sthāyī-bhāva, which we discussed as permanent ecstasy or continuous ecstasy that I am Krishna’s servant, or I am Krishna’s friend, or I’m Krishna’s guardian, or I’m Krishna’s girlfriend—such ecstasy is called sthāyī-bhāva—it always continues in the life of the devotee once he achieves it. And there are four other types of ecstasies which heighten the ecstasy of sthāyī-bhāva. When sthāyī-bhāva is mixed with the other ecstasies and is always in the supreme position, then that is rasa. In other words, the sthāyī-bhāva is compared to a king who subdues all other elements.

For example, Mother Yasoda has the sthāyī-bhāva of parental affection. She sees Krishna as her son. So when she sees that Krishna has been entwined by the Kaliya serpent, she’ll feel so many other ecstasies like compassion, dread, so many different ecstasies will come, but they will just heighten the ecstasy of the mood of being Krishna’s mother. They won’t be able to overwhelm the mood of being Krishna’s mother or break the mood of being Krishna’s mother because even in say, parental affection, there may be some element of friendship, wherein in the friendly relationship there may be some element of servitorship or parental affection, but the sthāyī-bhāva will always remain. It will never be diminished. The other bhāva especially the vyabhicāri are compared to waves in the ocean of sthāyī-bhāva, and they bring the sthāyī-bhāva to a higher level like a wave, and then they again go down into the ocean of sthāyī- bhāva. So they heighten the sthāyī-bhāva, but the sthāyī-bhāva is permanent, and when the sthāyī-bhāva mixes with the other types of ecstasy, the other ingredients, that becomes rasa.

For example, Damodara Swami gives the example of Srila Prabhupada—he uses the example of Srila Prabhupada, but just having the idea that I’m Srila Prabhupada’s disciple is not complete, but there should also be other ingredients. Just like when one sees Srila Prabhupada, he’ll offer obeisances which is like an anubhāva in the sense that it’s an activity that follows, and he is given some other examples that we might mention when we read about the other bhāvas. Text Forty-seven:

TRANSLATION

When the permanent ecstasies [neutrality, servitorship and so on] are mixed with other ingredients, devotional service in love of Godhead is transformed and becomes composed of transcendental mellows.

COMMENT

In the purport Srila Prabhupada quotes from Bhakti-rasāmṛta-sindhu:

PURPORT

Love for Kṛṣṇa, Keśava, as previously described, reaches the supreme state of being composed of mellows or rasas when its ingredients are fulfilled. By means of vibhāva, anubhāva, sāttvika and vyabhicārī, hearing and chanting are activated, and the devotee is able to taste love for Kṛṣṇa. Then attachment for Kṛṣṇa, or permanent ecstasy (sthāyi-bhāva), becomes the mellow of devotional service (bhakti-rasa).”

TEXT 48

Sthāyī-bhāva becomes more and more tasteful, and more and more tasteful transcendental mellow through the mixture of the vibhāva, anubhāva, sāttvika-bhāva, vyabhicārī-bhāva.

TEXT 49

Yogurt mixed with sugar candy, black pepper, and camphor is very palatable and tasty. Similarly, when permanent ecstasy mixes with other ecstatic symptoms, it becomes unprecedentedly tasty.

TEXT 50

“There are two kinds of particular ecstasies [vibhāva]. One is called the support (ālambana), and the other is called the awakening (uddīpana). The vibration of Kṛṣṇa’s flute is an example of the awakening, and Lord Kṛṣṇa Himself is an example of the support.”

COMMENT

Now here some explanation is in order. The vibhāvas are the impetuses or stimulations for ecstatic love of Krishna, and the vibhāvas come in two categories: ālambana means either the subject of the love or the object of the love, which in Sanskrit are called āśraya and viṣaya. Āśraya is the devotee who possesses love for Krishna, and if one sees the devotee who possesses love for Krishna then his ecstatic love is enhanced, or if he sees Krishna, his ecstatic love is enhanced. Or we can say that the basis of his expanded love or the foundation of his ecstatic love are the devotees who possess the same type of love for Krishna and Krishna because rasa exists in relation to Krishna. And every devotee will have some particular relationship with Krishna. So in particular when he sees another devotee who has that type of love for Krishna, his own ecstasy, that’s the basis of his ecstasy and along with Krishna.

Just like again Dhanudhar Swami gives the example that if one sees Srila Prabhupada his ecstatic feelings will be enhanced, and if one sees an intimate disciple of Srila Prabhupada then also his love for Srila Prabhupada will be enhanced. So if suddenly we saw Satsvarupa Maharaja, and immediately we would remember Srila Prabhupada, our mood of devotion to Srila Prabhupada will come out.

Devotee: [Unintelligible]

Giriraj Swami: Āśraya is the abode of love of the devotee and viṣaya is Krishna. So in dāsya-rasa, the āśraya will be Raktaka and Patraka, in sākhya-rasa will be Subal or Madhumangala, in vātsalya-rasa the āśraya will be Nanda Maharaja and Mother Yasoda, and in mādhurya-rasa the āśraya will be Srimati Radharani and Her associates; and the viṣaya is always Krishna.

Devotee: [Unintelligible]

Giriraj Swami: Krishna has for example three ages in Vrindavan called kaumāra, paugaṇḍa, and kaiśora. So the kaumāra age specifically is attractive to the devotees in vātsalya-rasa because Krishna’s a baby, He appears like a baby; and the paugaṇḍa age is especially attractive to the cowherd friends of Krishna because in the paugaṇḍa age, Krishna leaves the house and goes into the pasturing grounds with the boys and enjoys so many pastimes throughout the day; and then the kaiśora age, Krishna comes into youth, and he begins to enjoy youthful pastimes with the younger gopīs. So although the viṣaya is always Krishna, but the particular form of Krishna that is the object of ecstatic love will vary according to the devotee’s relationship.

Devotee: [Unintelligible]

Giriraj Swami: Āśraya and viṣaya are two divisions of ālambana. It says here kṛṣṇādi — ‘ālambana’ Krishna and others are the ālambana and then the uddīpana, the example is given of the vibration of Krishna’s flute. Things related to Krishna besides the abode of the love and the object of the love, those also awaken ecstatic love for Krishna or ecstatic feelings for Krishna, and they also vary according to one’s relationship.

Just like when Krishna’s teeth start to come into His mouth, that will give great ecstasy to Mother Yasoda in a way that the gopīs won’t get ecstasy. So Bhakti-rasāmṛta-sindhu has given detailed lists of the for different rasas, different bhāvas, all the different types of ecstasy in relation to the different types of rasas. Then anubhāvas—Text Fifty-one.

TEXT 51

“The anubhāvas are smiling, dancing and singing, as well as different manifestations in the body. The sāttvika-bhāvas such as being stunned, are considered among the anubhāva.”

COMMENT

Here in the purport of (Text Fifty) it mentions:

PURPORT

 “The cause bringing about the tasting of love for Kṛṣṇa is called vibhāva. Vibhāva is divided into two categories — ālambana (support) and uddīpana (awakening).”

That which causes love for Kṛṣṇa to appear is called vibhāva.

In the Bhakti-rasāmṛta-sindhu, the following is stated about ālambana:

The object of love is Kṛṣṇa, and the container of that love is the devotee of Kṛṣṇa. Both of them by learned scholars are called ālambana. Similarly, uddīpana is described;

Those things which awaken ecstatic love are called uddīpana. Mainly this awakening is made possible by the qualities and activities of Kṛṣṇa, as well as by His mode of decoration and the way His hair is arranged.”

Kṛṣṇa’s smile, the fragrance of His transcendental body, His flute, bugle, ankle bells and conchshell, the marks on His feet, His place of residence, His favorite plant [tulasī], His devotees, and the observance of fasts and vows connected to His devotion all awaken the symptoms of ecstatic love.”

COMMENT

Just like when Akrura, when he went to Vrindavan he saw the lotus footprints of Krishna in the sand and seeing the lotus footprints of Krishna, ecstasy was awakened in him. He came down from the chariot, tears flowed from his eyes, his body started to tremble, and he exhibited so many kinds of ecstasy by seeing the footprints of Krishna. Or Lord Chaitanya’s devotee, Mukunda dasa was the court physician of the Mohammedan king. So once he was sitting with the king on a high platform discussing some medical treatment and one of the king’s servants brought a peacock-feathered fan to keep over the head of the king to block the sun. So when he saw the peacock feathers, his ecstatic love for Krishna became awakened, and he fell from the platform and the king thought he might have died because it was a high platform. So he himself came down from the platform to see what happened to Mukunda dasa, and he asked “Mukunda, what happened?” He said, “I have some disease like epilepsy,” but the king was very intelligent. He knew what happened, and he realized that Mukunda dasa was some very extraordinary devotee. So these are uddīpana—any object connected with Krishna that awakens ecstatic love.

Devotee: [Unintelligible]

Giriraj Swami: You mean if you see some ordinary cowherd boy in Vrindavan.

Devotee: [Unintelligible]

Giriraj Swami: You mean Subal or Sridham? Or do you mean like what we have in the. . .

Devotee: [Unintelligible]

Giriraj Swami: Well, then it would be an uddīpana.

Devotee: [Unintelligible]

Giriraj Swami: If he actually has love for Krishna then he is āśraya, he is the container of the love, but otherwise he is just acting to remind you of Krishna.

Devotee: [Unintelligible]

Giriraj Swami: But here, we are talking about rasa. We were talking about a very high state, where the devotee has attained bhāva-bhakti, and the different bhāvas mixing together form rasa which is prema; we are not talking about ourselves.

Devotee: [Unintelligible]

Giriraj Swami: Anyway, we should stick to the subject and keep in mind that we are discussing a highly advanced stage and what the bhāva-bhakta or prema-bhakta experiences, it may have some resemblance to what we experience, but it’s not exactly the same. So when we see a peacock feather and it reminds us of Krishna, it’s good but we can’t say that the peacock feather is uddīpana unless the effect is actually bhāva.

Devotee: [Unintelligible]

Giriraj Swami: Okay, now in Bhakti-rasāmṛta-sindhu, anubhāva is described as follows: some of them are dancing, falling down and rolling on the ground, singing and crying very loudly, bodily contortions, loud vibrations, yawning, deep breathing, disregard for others, the frothing of saliva, mad laughter, spitting hiccups, and other similar symptoms. So there are so many but the list of nine characteristics are regular features of the bhāva-bhakta as opposed to the temporary manifestations which are also called anubhāvas because they're external manifestations or activities that follow bhāva-bhakti. I think we have to keep going because there is a little more to cover. Then Text Fifty-two discusses vyabhicārī-bhāva:

TRANSLATION

There are other ingredients, beginning with complete despondency and jubilation. Altogether there are thirty-three varieties, and when these combine, the mellow becomes very wonderful.

COMMENT

So the vyabhicārī-bhāva are transitory elements and sometimes they’re called disturbing elements. Because they set in motion the progress of the permanent sentiments, they are specifically called sañcārī, or impelling principles. These impelling principles rise up and fall back in the permanent sentiments of ecstatic love like waves in an ocean of ecstasy. Consequently, they are called vyabhicārī.”

Devotee: How do they differ from the [Unintelligible]

Giriraj Swami: They are more fleeting and they specifically enhance the sthāyī- bhāva where the other bhāvas are ecstatic symptoms that follow from the internal bhāvas. So they follow it. Just like within my heart I feel jubilation, so I dance. So the dancing is about anubhāva because it follows the ecstasy of jubilation. Everything enhances, everything enhances, but the anubhāvas are external manifestations that follow an internal state whereas the vyabhicārī-bhāvas, they affect the internal the sthāyī-bhāva, which is internal they affected.

Devotee:

Giriraj Swami: Yeah, but the sthāyī-bhāva mixes with other bhāvas. Like I have the sthāyī- bhāva that I’m Krishna’s, changing of color and so many things which are anubhāva and then if I notice say I’m a gopī and then if I notice that some elder family member is seeing my ecstatic transformation upon hearing the sound of Krishna’s flute, then I may feel some other emotion like shame, fear, which can be like a vyabhicārī-bhāva. That it’s apparently a disturbing element but it actually adds to the ecstasy of the sthāyī-bhāva but the main thing to remember is that these are all transformations of śuddha-sattva, there is nothing of the material world.

TEXT 53

pañca-vidha rasa — śānta, dāsya, sakhya, vātsalya
madhura-nāma śṛṅgāra-rasa — sabāte prābalya

TRANSLATION

“There are five transcendental mellows — neutrality, servitorship, friendship, parental affection and conjugal love, which is also known as the mellow of sweetness. Conjugal love excels all others.”

COMMENT

Then Lord Chaitanya explains how prema brings one up to the stage of śānta-rasa. Rāga, I think it refers to Vrindavan in particular, brings one from the stage of dāsya-rasa because in other places, it is said that sneha—if sneha is just added to prema it brings one to dāsya-rasa. Then anurāga can bring one to sākhya-rasa or vātsalya-rasa, and in the case of priya-narmā sakhās—special intimate boyfriends like Subal, there is bhāva more than anurāga bhāva, then in Srimati Radharani and the gopīs in mādhurya-rasa there is mahā-bhāva. 

Now in Bhakti-rasāmṛta-sindhu, Srila Rupa Gosvami says that the transformations beyond prema are very rarely seen in the material world, and therefore he doesn’t discuss them in Bhakti-rasāmṛta-sindhu, but he has written another book called Ujjvala-nīlamaṇi that deals especially with śṛṅgāra-rasa and which naturally includes the higher transformations of love.

So here Lord Chaitanya discusses various subjects relating to śṛṅgāra-rasa and Srila Prabhupada quotes various verses from Ujjvala-nīlamaṇi to elaborate.

Now let’s discuss one item which is very important for us. Text Sixty-three:

TEXT 63

‘vipralambha’ catur-vidha — pūrva-rāga, māna
pravāsākhya, āra prema-vaicittya-ākhyāna

TRANSLATION

“Vipralambha has four divisions — pūrva-rāga, māna, pravāsa and prema-vaicittya.”

COMMENT

Now in śṛṅgāra-rasa or mādhurya-rasa, there are two features—one is meeting which is called sambhoga and the other is separation which is called vipralambha. Devotees in the material world cultivate the mood of vipralambha as Lord Chaitanya expresses in the Śikṣāṣṭakam. Karma prabhu, can you quote the verse?

Devotee:

yugāyitaṁ nimeṣeṇa

cakṣuṣā prāvṛṣāyitam

śūnyāyitaṁ jagat sarvaṁ

govinda-viraheṇa me

COMMENT

This is the mood of vipralambha, where the devotee feels that in separation from Krishna, one moment is like many ages and the whole world appears vacant in the absence of Krishna. So devotees in the material world should cultivate the same mood of vipralambha as Lord Chaitanya, and His other associates demonstrated and especially the mood of when one becomes advanced the mood of pūrva-rāga. Pūrva-rāga is the state of separation that exists before the beloved meets Krishna or in other words when the devotee falls in love with Krishna before the devotee has actually met Krishna. That is pūrva-rāga.

Rupa Gosvami has written a nice drama it’s called Vidagdha-mādhava in which he discusses pūrva-rāga in the beginning. Before Srimati Radharani met Krishna, someone told her the name of Krishna and hearing the name of Krishna, she felt ecstatic love. Then after some time she heard the sound of the flute of Krishna, and the sound of Krishna’s flute also awakened ecstatic love. Then she saw the picture of Krishna and seeing the picture of Krishna also awakened ecstatic love in Her, but She didn’t know who is Krishna. So there is one very nice verse in Vidagdha-mādhava where Srimati Radharani says that, “I have heard the name of some person named Krishna, and ever since hearing the name I’ve lost all of my senses. Then again, I heard the flute of someone in the forest of Vrindavan, and since hearing the flute I become mad. Then again, I’ve seen the face of some very beautiful effulgent person, and I become so attracted to that person.” She didn’t know about Krishna, so She thought that. So in the verse She says that, “I am so unfortunate; I have become attracted to three different persons, and I do not know what to do, I do not know how I will be able to maintain my life,” because all of the gopīs were very chaste young girls from very good pious families, and they didn’t even want anyone to know that they were attracted to even one man. So you can imagine someone being so much attracted to whom She thought were three persons, how could she ever deal with such a critical situation? So this is pūrva-rāga, and there are descriptions in the Tenth Canto, how the young gopīs became attracted to Krishna, how they desired to have association with Krishna, how they observed vows to the Goddess Katyayani for the sake of getting Krishna and so on. So this is pūrva-rāga, longing for the opportunity to associate with Krishna before the first meeting.

Devotee: [Unintelligible]

Giriraj Swami: At the end of the description, he says that non-devotees cannot understand. For one who has dedicated everything to the lotus feet of Krishna can. Text 100–99 and 100—some of the discussions are appearing to be somewhat technical because we don’t have any realization, but we should have some idea of the goal, we should have some idea of the devotees, so that we can when we read books like Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam we can understand more clearly what’s happening. Like when we read that Uddhava comes to Vrindavan and he sees the lotus footprints of Krishna in the sand, and he feels ecstasy. We can understand the different types of ecstasy and the different ingredients of rasa, but it is a high subject.

Devotee: [Unintelligible]

Giriraj Swami: It should. That’s the idea, that when we know what the goal is and how wonderful is Krishna, we should be inspired to make more progress towards the goal and at the same time not to commit offenses when we read or hear the descriptions of pure devotees, to know that the devotees are experiencing transcendental ecstasy, which may resemble material emotions but which are not material at all.

Devotee: [Unintelligible]

Giriraj swami: Very good point. The actual explanation is that the ecstasies are experienced in the spiritual body, and the material body which has also become spiritualized becomes the obedient servant of the spiritual body. So first there are tears in the spiritual body, and then there are tears in the material body, which is not really material anyway because it’s completely dedicated to Krishna’s service. Yes, exactly. Because when one is in bhāva, his svarūpa comes out.

Devotee: [Unintelligible]

Giriraj Swami: Not bhāva. There is svarūpa-siddhi which means the spiritual body has come out, but there is still some material connection, some traces of something. There are some slight disturbances in bhāva, which are generally due to past offenses especially vaiṣṇava-aparādha. They create some disturbance, but only temporarily because the force of bhāva is so powerful that the bhāva will carry the person to prema, but temporarily there might be. Just like Lord Chaitanya, when Lord Chaitanya was a teacher, He was chanting the names of the gopīs, and then some students came and said, “Why are You chanting the names of the gopīs? You should be chanting the names of Krishna.” Now in His inner mood, He was in the anger of love with Krishna, māna, but when the students disturbed Him and said, “You should chant the name of Krishna,” He became angry at them. Because in His spiritual, of course everything about Lord Chaitanya is spiritual, but say in His inner mood, He was in the mood of the anger of love towards Krishna, and then when the students disturbed Him and said, “You should chant the name of Krishna,” He became angry at them. So sometimes the inner mood expresses itself in the outward body, and that’s the case in bhāva. That the moods or the emotions in the siddha-deha become manifest also in the physical deha, which is not physical but because outward. . .

Devotee: [Unintelligible]

Giriraj Swami: As I mentioned the bhāvas don’t disappear with prema, prema doesn’t disappear with sneha, sneha doesn’t disappear with mahā-bhāva. They go on increasing. So the bhāvas are there, at the beginning of bhāva, but when the bhāvas intensify and the five bhāvas including sthāyī-bhāva mix together, then it becomes prema.

Devotee: [Unintelligible]

Giriraj Swami: Yeah, when they mix together, and the sthāyī-bhāva maintains the preeminent position, as the king of the others—that forms rasa, that’s prema. It’s not different, it’s just more intense.

Devotee: [Unintelligible]

Giriraj Swami: Yeah, because it’s a gradual progression, it’s not that that one is black and the other is white, but it becomes more and more intensified, and at a certain stage the intensity is called and even then, the prema can become more intense, then it’s called sneha, when you get other transformations. So they’re not different entities, it’s just different stages of maturity of the same entity.

Devotee: [Unintelligible]

Giriraj Swami: Well, in English sometimes the same word has different meanings and we know from the context, and if there is any doubt or ambiguity then the speaker can clarify that this is this bhāva and not that bhāva. I’ll answer your yesterday’s question for two seconds because you are already late.

Greed, greed can appear at any stage, but when greed appears, one will come to. . . At least must be ruci and he will come very quickly to āsakti. Like Bilva Mangala Thakura, in one sense, had no stage, he was a woman hunter but when the prostitute Chintamani told him that, “If you had the same affection for Krishna as you have for me, it would be much better,” then her words awakened his greed, and then he left everything to go to Vrindavan to get Krishna. So in one sense, what you could say, he wasn’t even on the platform of bhajana-kriyā, he wasn’t on any platform, but because of past life’s development, the words of the prostitute awakened his greed and when his greed was awakened, he immediately went to a higher stage but at least there has to be ruci or taste because greed is a spontaneous attraction for something. It’s not based on obligation to scriptural injunctions or guru’s instructions. So there has to be taste, and real greed is strong, and from the taste one will come to deep attachment, and then when he gets the mercy of Krishna or some advanced devotee, then the bhāva will appear. But greed is independent of any stage but when greed appears, it will take one, there has to be some ruci and it will take one to āsakti.

Devotee: So lower levels of bhajana-kriyā and [Unintelligible]

Giriraj Swami: No, greed means there has to be ruci. Greed means there has to be ruci.

Devotee: [Unintelligible]

Giriraj Swami: He was at no stage—no shraddha, no sādhu-saṅga, he was strī-saṅgī.

Devotee: [Unintelligible]

Giriraj Swami: He was advanced in his previous life, but he fell down. Like Rupa Gosvami says, only way to achieve greed is by the mercy of the Lord or the devotee. And that if one has greed without the association of the devotee or without the association of a guru, but spontaneously he has greed and then he looks for a guru or a devotee to guide him, then it’s understood that he has received the mercy in the past life, but if one first associates with the guru and by the mercy of the guru one then develops a greed, that’s from the present life. So the appearance of greed is not dependent on any stage of practice.

Devotee: [Unintelligible]

Giriraj Swami: By the mercy of the Lord or the Vaishnava. But, generally if we are going by the normal course, we can say that when there is some ruci, there can be some greed, but then when real greed comes, the greed itself will take the devotee to āsakti and then the practices of rāganuga-bhakti that we read are described in the Śrī Caitanya-caritāmṛta they can come. But in a preliminary sense, there can be some greed, some little greed, some little taste, even in earlier stages and the little greed and the little taste will help one to more quickly pass through anarthas and other problems, and then we come to the stage of ruci. 

Devotee: Processing through all these stages one [Unintelligible]

Giriraj Swami: You see, I’ll clarify this because we didn’t actually get to discuss it fully. I was speaking about attaining bhāva by the mercy of Krishna or the devotee. You see, the immediate cause of bhāva-bhakti is advanced sādhana-bhakti beginning with niṣṭhā especially ruci and then āsakti. Now if someone is at a lower stage of sādhana-bhakti, and he suddenly develops bhāva-bhakti that is due to kṛpā. It doesn’t mean that the person sits at home all day and watches television and then he gets kṛpā, and he develops bhāva. He is making his own efforts, but he is very lowly and slowly making progress but because of some quality in him or some service, he becomes the recipient of some mercy, and then he advances to the stage of bhāva, even with [Unintelligible].

So if someone is somewhere there in sādhana-bhakti, but by his good qualities or his good efforts or some good service, he gets the mercy of the Lord or the devotee then without going through the gradual process, he can be immediately elevated to prema-bhakti. So here the mercy means that the devotee will be able to pass over, or if you wanted to say pass through at once, some intermediate stages. Yeah, like Jagai and Madhai. Good example.

Giriraj Swami: Many people who saw Lord Chaitanya were embraced by Lord Chaitanya, they immediately became advanced.

Devotee: The slokas that you have—are those the only ones that we need to know?

Giriraj Swami: No, those are some that that you definitely have to know for the test, but it doesn’t mean that those will be the only ones that you’ll have to know for the test. Well you should know. . . Let’s see. Sometimes, usually at the beginning of class, I’ll ask some questions about what we covered in the last class, and the questions I asked will relate to points that are important, you know what it means. And I could also tell you that you should know what is ekaṅga-bhakti and aneka-aṅga or bahu-aṅga bhakti. You should know the nine processes of devotional service beginning with śravaṇam, smaraṇam, Vishnu. You should know which devotees attained success by which process.

Devotee: [Unintelligible]

Giriraj Swami: Well you have to know the subject; you may not need to know the exact words, but you have to know the substance beyond just the ones that are mentioned. We should know the nine characteristics of one in ecstatic love for Krishna. Those are the other questions that I’ve asked at the beginning of the classes from the previous day’s discussion. That’s five minutes—it’s just a drop from the ocean. The test will be like an ocean, and it would be almost impossible to cross it. I’m just giving you a few drops. Srila Prabhupada ki jaya!

The publisher assumes no responsibility for any errors or omissions in the content of the transcriptions provided on the site. The information contained in these transcribed lectures has not been exhaustively edited and is provided on an "as-is" basis with no guarantees of accuracy.
Dive into the Nectar

Books by Giriraj Swami

Deepen Your Spiritual Journey

Weekly Inspiration from Giriraj Swami

Sign up to receive weekly emails with exclusive content from Giriraj Swami, including recent lectures, excerpts from upcoming books, and announcements about workshops and retreats. Dive deeper into Krishna consciousness and stay connected with a community of like-minded seekers on your spiritual path.

Name(Required)