CC Antya 16 – Don’t Imitate the Maha-bhagavatas
Durban, South Africa
Giriraj Swami: Reading from Caitanya-caritāmṛta, Antya-līlā, Chapter Sixteen - “Lord Śrī Caitanya Mahāprabhu Tastes Nectar from the Lips of Lord Śrī Kṛṣṇa.”
The Sixteenth Chapter is summarized by Śrīla Bhaktivinoda Ṭhākura in his Amṛta-pravāha-bhāṣya. When the Bengali devotees of the Lord returned to Jagannātha Purī, a gentleman named Kālidāsa, who was an uncle of Raghunātha dāsa Gosvāmī, went with them to see Śrī Caitanya Mahāprabhu. Kālidāsa had tasted the remnants of food of all the Vaiṣṇavas in Bengal, even Jhaḍu Ṭhākura. Because of this, he received the shelter of Śrī Caitanya Mahāprabhu at Jagannātha Purī.
When Kavi-karṇapūra was only seven years old, he was initiated by Śrī Caitanya Mahāprabhu into the Hare Kṛṣṇa mahā-mantra. He later became the greatest poet among the Vaiṣṇava ācāryas.
When Śrī Caitanya Mahāprabhu ate the remnants of food known as vallabha-bhoga, He described the glories of such remnants of the Lord’s food and then fed all the devotees the prasādam. Thus they all tasted adharāmṛta, the nectar from the lips of Lord Śrī Kṛṣṇa.
TEXT 1
vande śrī-kṛṣṇa-caitanyaṁ
kṛṣṇa-bhāvāmṛtaṁ hi yaḥ
āsvādyāsvādayan bhaktān
prema-dīkṣām aśikṣayat
TRANSLATION
Let me offer my respectful obeisances unto Śrī Caitanya Mahāprabhu, who personally tasted the nectar of ecstatic love for Kṛṣṇa and then instructed His devotees how to taste it. Thus He enlightened them about ecstatic love of Kṛṣṇa to initiate them into transcendental knowledge.
TEXT 2
jaya jaya śrī-caitanya jaya nityānanda
jayādvaita-candra jaya gaura-bhakta-vṛnda
All glories to Śrī Caitanya Mahāprabhu! All glories to Lord Nityānanda! All glories to Advaita Ācārya! And all glories to all the devotees of the Lord!
TEXT 3
Śrī Caitanya Mahāprabhu thus stayed at Jagannātha Purī in the association of His devotees, always merged in ecstatic devotional love.
TEXT 4
The next year, as usual, all the devotees from Bengal went to Jagannātha Purī, and, as in previous years, there was a meeting between Śrī Caitanya Mahāprabhu and the devotees.
TEXT 5
Along with the devotees from Bengal came a gentleman named Kālidāsa. He never uttered anything but the holy name of Kṛṣṇa.
TEXT 6
Kālidāsa was a very advanced devotee, yet he was simple and liberal. He would chant the holy name of Kṛṣṇa while performing all his ordinary dealings.
TEXT 7
When he used to throw dice in jest, he would chant Hare Kṛṣṇa while throwing the dice.
PURPORT by Srila Prabhupada
In this connection Śrīla Bhaktisiddhānta Sarasvatī Ṭhākura warns the men of this age not to imitate the jesting of a mahā-bhāgavata like Kālidāsa. If someone imitates him by playing with dice or gambling while chanting the Hare Kṛṣṇa mahā-mantra, he will certainly become a victim of offenses unto the holy name. As it is said, hari-nāma-bale pāpe pravṛtti: one must not commit sinful activities on the strength of chanting the Hare Kṛṣṇa mantra. Playing with dice is certainly gambling, but it is clearly said here that Kālidāsa did this only in jest. A mahā-bhāgavata can do anything, but he never forgets the basic principles. Therefore it is said, tāṅra vākya, kriyā-mudrā vijñeha nā bujhaya: “No one can understand the activities of a pure devotee.” We should not imitate Kālidāsa.
COMMENT
Amongst the associates of Sri Chaitanya Mahaprabhu were many liberated souls or mahā-bhāgavatas, but sometimes their character and their activities resemble those of karmis. And Even the other associates of Sri Chaitanya Mahaprabhu sometimes became bewildered by seeing them. We have the example of Pundarika Vidyanidhi. Pundarika Vidyanidhi was mahā-bhāgavata but he appeared like a rich man having a big house, having servants, having nice clothes, and having attendants, eating nice food. So when another devotee took Gadadhara Pandit to meet him, Gadadhara Pandit had some doubt that he seemed to be a materialistic person. The other devotee, perceiving the doubt in the mind of Gadadhara Prabhu, started to recite some pastimes of Krishna from Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam. As soon as Pundarika Vidyanidhi heard the pastimes of Krishna from the Bhāgavatam, he merged into the ocean of transcendental bliss and began to manifest various symptoms of transcendental ecstasy. Then Gadadhara Pandit could understand the exalted position of Pundarika Vidyanidhi.
Another example is Ramananda Raya. One devotee of Lord Chaitanya named Pradyumna Misra approached the Lord to speak to Him kṛṣṇa-kathā. Lord Chaitanya declined, He said that I do not know anything about transcendental mellows. Whatever I know about transcendental mellows, I had learned from Ramananda Raya. He instructed Pradyumna Misra to go to Ramananda and ask Him to speak on kṛṣṇa-kathā. So Pradyumna Misra went, and Ramananda Raya was in the inner courtyard. He was not available, so Pradyumna Misra waited for some time. In the meantime, Ramananda Raya’s servant came and asked Pradyumna Misra what do you want? Pradyumna Misra replied that I wanted to meet Raya Ramananda. The servant said that Raya Ramananda was engaged just now but would meet him after some time. Pradyumna Misra asked what Ramananda was doing. The servant replied that he is training some devadasis, or some young girls, to dance for the pleasure of Jagannatha.
Actually what Ramananda Raya used to do he used to personally bathe them with his own hands, he used to rub oil on their bodies, he used to dress them and decorate them, and train them in the gestures and roles of the part that they have to play in his drama. Ramananda Raya wrote one very famous drama called Jagannatha Vallabha Natakam, and he personally trained the devadasis to play the roles of gopīs in the drama in detail. When Pradyumna Misra understood what Ramananda Raya was doing, He was shocked. He left the house of Ramananda Raya without hearing kṛṣṇa-kathā from him and went back to Lord Chaitanya. Lord Chaitanya asked, “So did you hear kṛṣṇa-kathā from Ramananda Raya?” He said, “No, he was busy when I went there.” Lord Chaitanya could understand the mind of Pradyumna Misra and He said “Do you have any doubt about Him?”
Then everything came out Lord Chaitanya said to Pradyumna Misra that as far as I can understand, Ramananda Raya had no material affection for any women. He is completely liberated. Even if they hear the voice of a woman or see the model of a woman, our body would experience some transformation. But Ramananda Raya, even if he touches the naked body of young girls, he remains unaffected, just like wood, there is no change at all. Pradyumna Misra wondered, “How do you know?” Lord Chaitanya answered that I can surmise on the basis of scripture and then quoted one verse from the Tenth Canto of Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam:
vikrīḍitaṁ vraja-vadhūbhir idaṁ ca viṣṇoḥ
That if one with faith and eagerness hears about the playful activities of Lord Krishna with the young damsels of Vrindavan or describes such activities, his heart becomes filled with transcendental love of Krishna, and he very quickly becomes sober and he becomes cured of the disease of the heart called lust.” Lord Chaitanya said that on the basis of the verse from Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam and the fact that Ramananda Raya is always absorbed in hearing and chanting about the pastimes of Krishna and the gopīs, that He must be completely free from lust. Some person may say that first the heart has to be freed from lust, then prema can enter the heart. But here, we find the opposite statement in Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam that if one hears and drinks the nectar of the pastimes of Krishna with thirsty ears, then the nectar will enter the heart, fill the heart with love of Krishna, and wash away the lust.
So, from the examples of Kalidas, Pundarika Vidyanidhi, and Ramananda Raya, we can understand as Srila Prabhupada quotes from Śrī Bhakti-Rasāmṛta-Sindhu vaiṣṇavera kriyā-mudrā vijñeha nā bujhaya nobody can understand the characteristics or activities of someone situated on the platform of love of Godhead. We can become bewildered, we can become confused, and we can commit offenses. In the case of Gadadhara Pandit, when he realized the offense he had committed against Pundarika Vidyanidhi, he wondered how he could mitigate the offenses and then He decided that he should accept Pundarika Vidyanidhi as a spiritual master and take initiation from him. In the case of Pradyumna Misra, after he heard the explanation of Lord Chaitanya, Lord Chaitanya said he should go back to Ramananda Raya and you should ask him to speak about kṛṣṇa-kathā. So Pradyumna Misra went back, he heard kṛṣṇa-kathā from the mouth of Ramananda Raya, and then returned to Lord Chaitanya, admitted the greatness of Ramananda Raya.
At the same time, we should not dare to try to imitate such mahā-bhāgavatas; otherwise, we will transgress the regulative principles and become implicated in offenses, which will create havoc. The scripture says that the great personalities are never contaminated by anything that they do, just like the sun can enter a filthy place where there is urine and the sun can evaporate the urine but the sun does not become contaminated. So that is possible for the sun or the great controllers of the universe. It is not possible for us. Therefore, the scripture says that we should follow the instructions of the great persons and not try to imitate them. Or we can follow in the footsteps of the great personalities but not try to imitate them.
TEXT 8
Kālidāsa was an uncle of Raghunātha dāsa Gosvāmī. Throughout his entire life, even in his old age, he tried to eat the remnants of food left by Vaiṣṇavas.
TEXT 9
Kālidāsa ate the remnants of food of as many Vaiṣṇavas as there were in Bengal.
TEXT 10
He would go to all the Vaiṣṇavas born in brāhmaṇa families, be they neophyte or advanced devotees, and present them with gifts of first-class eatables.
TEXT 11
He would beg remnants of food from such Vaiṣṇavas, and if he did not receive any, he would hide.
TEXT 12
After the Vaiṣṇavas finished eating, they would throw away their leaf dishes, and Kālidāsa would come out of hiding, take the leaves and lick up the remnants.
TEXT 13
He would also take gifts to the homes of Vaiṣṇavas born in śūdra families. Then he would hide and in this manner eat the remnants of food they threw away.
TEXT 14
There was a great Vaiṣṇava named Jhaḍu Ṭhākura, who belonged to the bhūṅimāli caste. Kālidāsa went to his home, taking mangoes with him.
PURPORT
Śrīla Bhaktisiddhānta Sarasvatī Ṭhākura remarks, “Both Kālidāsa and Jhaḍu Ṭhākura are worshiped at a place called Śrīpāṭabāṭī, in the village known as Bhedo or Bhaduyā. This village is situated about three miles south of the village of Kṛṣṇapura, the birthplace of Raghunātha dāsa Gosvāmī, which is about one mile west of the Bandel junction of the Burdwan line. A post office there is named Devānanda-pura.
COMMENT
Why Srila Prabhupada giving such information? Can anyone think? Nobody knows so that we can visit the place. Every devotee should want to visit the place of Lord Chaitanya pastimes and the places of Lord Chaitanya’s associates. Therefore Srila Prabhupada has given directions how to find the place.
PURPORT (continued)
Jhaḍu Ṭhākura used to worship the Deity of Śrī Madana-gopāla. The Deity is still worshiped by one Rāmaprasāda dāsa, who belongs to the Rāmāyet community. It is said that the Deity worshiped by Kālidāsa had been worshiped until recently in the village of Śaṅkha on the bank of the Sarasvatī River, but the Deity was taken away by a gentleman named Matilāla Caṭṭopādhyāya from the village of Triveṇī. The Deity is now being worshiped at his place.”
COMMENT
So the devotees are interested in the Lord and the Lord’s associates, as well as in the deities worshiped by the Lord’s associates. They also like to see the deities and offer respect to the deities that were personally worshiped by the Lord’s associates.
TEXT 15
Kālidāsa presented the mangoes to Jhaḍu Ṭhākura and offered him respectful obeisances. Then he also offered respectful obeisances to the Ṭhākura’s wife.
TEXT 16
When Kālidāsa went to Jhaḍu Ṭhākura, he saw that saintly person sitting with his wife. As soon as Jhaḍu Ṭhākura saw Kālidāsa, he likewise offered his respectful obeisances unto him.
TEXT 17
After a discussion with Kālidāsa that lasted for some time, Jhaḍu Ṭhākura spoke the following sweet words.
TEXT 18
“āmi — nīca-jāti, tumi, — atithi sarvottama
kon prakāre karimu āmi tomāra sevana?
TRANSLATAION
“I belong to a low caste, and you are a very respectable guest. How shall I serve you?
TEXT 19
“If you will permit me, I shall send some food to a brāhmaṇa’s house, and there you may take prasādam. If you do so, I shall then live very comfortably.”
TEXT 20
kālidāsa kahe, — “ṭhākura, kṛpā kara more
tomāra darśane āinu mui patita pāmare
TRANSLATION
Kālidāsa replied, “My dear sir, please bestow your mercy upon me. I have come to see you, although I am very fallen and sinful.
TEXT 21
“Simply by seeing you, I have become purified. I am very much obligated to you, for my life is now successful.
TEXT 22
“My dear sir, I have one desire. Please be merciful to me by kindly placing your feet upon my head so that the dust on your feet may touch it.”
TEXT 23
Jhaḍu Ṭhākura replied, “It does not befit you to ask this of me. I belong to a very low-caste family, whereas you are a respectable rich gentleman.”
TEXT 24
Kālidāsa then recited some verses, which Jhaḍu Ṭhākura was very happy to hear.
TEXT 25
na me ‘bhaktaś catur-vedī
mad-bhaktaḥ śva-pacaḥ priyaḥ
tasmai deyaṁ tato grāhyaṁ
sa ca pūjyo yathā hy aham
TRANSLATION
“ ‘Even though one is a very learned scholar in Sanskrit literature, if he is not engaged in pure devotional service, he is not accepted as My devotee. But if someone born in a family of dog-eaters is a pure devotee with no motives for enjoyment through fruitive activity or mental speculation, he is very dear to Me. All respect should be given to him, and whatever he offers should be accepted, for such devotees are indeed as worshipable as I am.’
PURPORT
This verse, spoken by the Supreme Personality of Godhead, is found in the Hari-bhakti-vilāsa.
TEXT 26
viprād dvi-ṣaḍ-guṇa-yutād aravinda-nābha-
pādāravinda-vimukhāt śva-pacaṁ variṣṭham
manye tad-arpita-mano-vacanehitārtha-
prāṇaṁ punāti sa kulaṁ na tu bhūri-mānaḥ
TRANSLATION
“ ‘A person may be born in a brāhmaṇa family and have all twelve brahminical qualities, but if in spite of being qualified he is not devoted to the lotus feet of Lord Kṛṣṇa, who has a navel shaped like a lotus, he is not as good as a caṇḍāla who has dedicated his mind, words, activities, wealth, and life to the service of the Lord. Simply to take birth in a brāhmaṇa family or to have brahminical qualities is not sufficient. One must become a pure devotee of the Lord. If a śva-paca or caṇḍāla is a devotee, he delivers not only himself but his whole family, whereas a brāhmaṇa who is not a devotee but simply has brahminical qualifications cannot even purify himself, what to speak of his family.’
PURPORT
This and the following verse are quoted from Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam (7.9.10 and 3.33.7).
COMMENT
Srila Prabhupada used to tell the story of one disciple named Karthikeya, whose mother was sick. So one who is a Vaishnava, even if he is born in a low family, can purify his whole family. And a brahman, even if he is born in a good family and has brahminical qualifications, but if he is not a Vaishnava, he cannot even purify himself, what to speak of others.
We see in the Tenth Canto of the Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam, the Lord Krishna sent His cowherd boyfriends to beg food from some Yajñic brahmans. But the Yajñic brahmans could not understand that Krishna and Balarama, who are the Supreme Personality of Godhead and the actual goal of all Vedic sacrifices, were playing as cowherd boys in the forest of Vrindavan and begging for food from them. They were proud of their brahminical qualifications and activities and refused to give any food to the cowherd boys for Krishna and Balarama. So although they were qualified brahmans, because they were not devotees, they themselves were not pure. And they could not even purify themselves. Even later, when they realized that Krishna and Balarama were the Supreme Personality of Godhead and condemned themselves for their bad behavior and made up their minds that they should go to Krishna and Balarama, but they could not do so because they were afraid of Kamsa. So even though they had intellectual knowledge that Krishna is the Supreme Personality of Godhead, they could not surrender to Him because they were not pure. They were still suffering from sinful reactions, and thus they could not render devotional service to Krishna and Balarama.
TEXT 27
aho bata śva-paco ‘to garīyān
yaj-jihvāgre vartate nāma tubhyam
tepus tapas te juhuvuḥ sasnur āryā
brahmānūcur nāma gṛṇanti ye te
TRANSLATION
“ ‘My dear Lord, anyone who always keeps Your holy name on his tongue is greater than an initiated brāhmaṇa. Although he may be born in a family of dog-eaters and therefore, by material calculations, be the lowest of men, he is glorious nevertheless. That is the wonderful power of chanting the holy name of the Lord. One who chants the holy name is understood to have performed all kinds of austerities. He has studied all the Vedas, he has performed all the great sacrifices mentioned in the Vedas, and he has already taken his bath in all the holy places of pilgrimage. It is he who is factually the Āryan.’ ”
TEXT 28
Hearing these quotations from the revealed scripture Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam, Jhaḍu Ṭhākura replied, “Yes, this is true, for it is the version of śāstra. It is true, however, for one who is genuinely advanced in devotion to Kṛṣṇa.
TEXT 29
“Such a position may befit others, but I do not possess such spiritual power. I belong to a lower class and have not even a pinch of devotion to Kṛṣṇa.”
PURPORT
In his statement, Jhaḍu Ṭhākura presents himself as being born in a low-caste family and not having the qualifications of a bona fide devotee of Lord Kṛṣṇa. He accepts the statements declaring a lowborn person highly exalted if he is a Vaiṣṇava. However, he feels that these descriptions from Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam appropriately describe others, but not himself. Jhaḍu Ṭhākura’s attitude is quite befitting a real Vaiṣṇava, for a Vaiṣṇava never considers himself exalted, even if he factually is. He is always meek and humble and never thinks that he is an advanced devotee. He assigns himself to a lower position, but that does not mean he is indeed low. Sanātana Gosvāmī once said that he belonged to a low-caste family, for although he was born in a brāhmaṇa family, he had associated with mlecchas and yavanas in his service as a government minister. Similarly, Jhaḍu Ṭhākura presented himself as someone who belonged to a low caste, but he was actually elevated above many persons born in brāhmaṇa families. Not only is there evidence for this in Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam, as quoted by Kālidāsa in verses 26 and 27, but there is also considerable evidence for this conclusion in other śāstras. For example, in the Mahābhārata (Vana-parva, chapter 177, verse 20), it is stated:
śūdre tu yad bhavel lakṣma dvije tac ca na vidyate
na vai śūdro bhavec chūdro brāhmaṇo na ca brāhmaṇaḥ
“If someone born a śūdra possesses the characteristics of a brāhmaṇa and someone born a brāhmaṇa does not, that śūdra should not be known as a śūdra, and that brāhmaṇa should not be known as a brāhmaṇa.”
Similarly, in the Vana-parva, Chapter 203, verses 11–12, it is said:
śūdra-yonau hi jātasya sad-guṇānupatiṣṭhataḥ
ārjave vartamānasya brāhmaṇyam abhijāyate
“If a person born in a śūdra family has developed the qualities of a brāhmaṇa, such as satya [truthfulness], śama [peacefulness], dama [self-control] and ārjava [simplicity], he attains the exalted position of a brāhmaṇa.”
And in the Anuśāsana-parva, chapter 163, it is said:
sthito brāhmaṇa-dharmeṇa brāhmaṇyam upajīvati
kṣatriyo vātha vaiśyo vā brahma-bhūyaḥ sa gacchati
ebhis tu karmabhir devi śubhair ācaritais tathā
śūdro brāhmaṇatāṁ yāti vaiśyaḥ kṣatriyatāṁ vrajet
na yonir nāpi saṁskāro na śrutaṁ na ca santatiḥ
kāraṇāni dvijatvasya vṛttam eva tu kāraṇam
“If one is factually situated in the occupation of a brāhmaṇa, he must be considered a brāhmaṇa, even if born in a kṣatriya or vaiśya family. O Devī, even if one is born a śūdra, if he is actually engaged in the occupation and pure behavior of a brāhmaṇa, he becomes a brāhmaṇa. Moreover, a vaiśya can become a kṣatriya. Therefore, neither the source of one’s birth nor his reformation nor his education is the criterion of a brāhmaṇa. The vṛtta, or occupation, is the real standard by which one is known as a brāhmaṇa.”
COMMENT
Srila Prabhupada gives the example that even if one is qualified in school as a lawyer or a doctor but if he doesn’t practice law or medicine, nobody will call him a lawyer or a doctor. He has to have the qualification and, at the same time, he has to engage in the profession. Then he can be called a doctor or a lawyer.
PURPORT (continued)
We have seen that a person who is not the son of a doctor and has not attended a medical college is sometimes able to practice medicine. By practical knowledge of how to perform a surgical operation, how to mix medicine and how to give certain medicines for certain diseases, a person can receive a certificate and be registered as a medical practitioner in the practical field. He can do a medical man’s work and be known as a doctor. Although qualified medical men may consider him a quack, the government will recognize his work. Especially in India, there are many such doctors who perform their medical services perfectly. They are accepted even by the government. Similarly, if one is engaged in brahminical service or occupational duties, he must be considered a brāhmaṇa despite the family in which he is born. That is the verdict of all the śāstras.
COMMENT
So when Srila Prabhupada returned to India with his foreign disciples, he created quite a sensation amongst caste-conscious Hindus. When Srila Prabhupada and the devotees arrived, they attracted tremendous publicity, and there were big articles in all newspapers and magazines. One article appeared in the Illustrated Weekly of India, which is the leading weekly of India, or maybe in the Times of India, which is the leading daily. Some person wrote to the editor complaining that the devotees coming from western families were being given brahminical initiation by Srila Prabhupada and were being called brahmans. Srila Prabhupada wrote a letter in reply and said that if a person knows how to practice law, he can be accepted as a lawyer and practice law, even if some lawyers who graduated from law school do not accept them as lawyers. They will be accepted as lawyers and can practice law. He said, in the same way, the ISKCON devotees who are initiated as brahmans and who act as brahmans they can perform brahminical activities and be accepted as brahmans, even if the caste Brahmins don’t accept them.
In the original article, it mentioned that one of the devotees named Gopal, before coming to the movement, had worked as a construction worker in America. So the author of the letter complained that he was acting as a construction worker, so how can he be a Brahmin? Srila Prabhupada replied in his letter that in the West, people believe in the dignity of work, and therefore if someone works hard, he is not considered low. Actually Srila Prabhupada condemned the caste-conscious Hindus for the fact that they did not like to work. They might have the qualifications of a sudra, but they wouldn’t do the work of a sudra because they thought they were born as brahmans or born as Kshatriyas. Srila Prabhupada wanted people to work hard, and in fact, he said that one of our programs for Vrindavan should be to pick up all the sadhus and bābās that are living in Vrindavan without doing any work and engage them in work. Put them to work in the field because they’re not real brahmans; they’re not doing the work of brahmans. They’re just eating and enjoying at the expense of others.
A Vaishnava can do any work. A Vaishnava is beyond any material designation, even Brahmin. Vaishnava can do any work. He can worship the deity in the morning and work in the fields in the afternoon. There is no problem. Srila Prabhupada quote further evidence in the Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam.
PURPORT (continued)
In Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam (7.11.35), it is said:
yasya yal lakṣaṇaṁ proktaṁ puṁso varṇābhivyañjakam
yad anyatrāpi dṛśyeta tat tenaiva vinirdiśet
This is a statement by Nārada Muni to Mahārāja Yudhiṣṭhira, wherein Nārada says that the symptoms of a brāhmaṇa, kṣatriya, and vaiśya are all described in the śāstra. Therefore, if one is found exhibiting the symptoms and qualities of a brāhmaṇa, kṣatriya, or vaiśya and serving in a brahminical, kṣatriya, or vaiśya occupation, even if he is not born a brāhmaṇa, kṣatriya, or vaiśya he should be considered such according to his qualifications and occupation.
Similarly, in the Padma purāṇa it is said:
na śūdrā bhagavad-bhaktās te tu bhāgavatā matāḥ
sarva-varṇeṣu te śūdrā ye na bhaktā janārdane
“A devotee should never be considered a śūdra. All the devotees of the Supreme Personality of Godhead should be recognized as bhāgavatas. If one is not a devotee of Lord Kṛṣṇa, however, even if born in a brāhmaṇa, kṣatriya, or vaiśya family, he should be considered a śūdra.”
COMMENT
Here, Padma Purāṇa says that if someone is a devotee, he should never be considered a sudra, but if someone is born as a brahman, kshatriya, or vaishya and is not a devotee, he should be considered a sudra, but we should not be proud and think that we are devotees. Even Jhaḍu Ṭhākura, who is the most exalted of Vaishnavas, did not think that the description of Vaishnavas in the scriptures applied to him.
PURPORT (continued)
In the Padma Purāṇa it is also said:
śva-pākam iva nekṣeta loke vipram avaiṣṇavam
vaiṣṇavo varṇo-bāhyo ‘pi punāti bhuvana-trayam
“If a person born in a brāhmaṇa family is an avaiṣṇava, a nondevotee, one should not see his face, exactly as one should not look upon the face of a caṇḍāla, or dog-eater. However, a Vaiṣṇava found in varṇas other than brāhmaṇa can purify all the three worlds.”
COMMENT
One reason that we should not become proud and think that the descriptions of Vaishnavas apply to us is because Vaishnava is a very exalted status. We should think, and actually it is so, that we are trying to become Vaishnavas or practicing to become Vaishnavas. But Vaishnava is such a wonderful thing that we don’t know when we will come to the position of Vaishnava, but we are continuing with our efforts.
PURPORT (continued)
The Padma Purāṇa further says:
śūdraṁ vā bhagavad-bhaktaṁ niṣādaṁ śva-pacaṁ tathā
vīkṣate jāti-sāmānyāt sa yāti narakaṁ dhruvam
“One who considers a devotee of the Supreme Personality of Godhead who was born in a family of śūdras, niṣādas, or caṇḍālas to belong to that particular caste certainly goes to hell.”
A brāhmaṇa must be a Vaiṣṇava and a learned scholar. Therefore in India it is customary to address a brāhmaṇa as paṇḍita. Without knowledge of Brahman, one cannot understand the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Therefore a Vaiṣṇava is already a brāhmaṇa, whereas a brāhmaṇa may become a Vaiṣṇava.
COMMENT
Brahma jānātīti brāhmaṇaḥ - A Brahmin is one who knows brahman, but the absolute truth is realized in three features: brahman, Paramātmā, and Bhagavān. Although a Brahmin may have knowledge of brahman, he may not have knowledge of Paramātmā and Bhagavān. But a Vaisnava will have knowledge of brahman, Paramātmā, and Bhagavān, and therefore he is more than an ordinary brahmin, and he is considered a real pundit.
PURPORT (continued)
In the Garuḍa Purāṇa it is said:
bhaktir aṣṭa-vidhā hy eṣā yasmin mlecche ‘pi vartate
sa viprendro muni-śreṣṭhaḥ sa jñānī sa ca paṇḍitaḥ
“Even if one is born a mleccha, if he becomes a devotee he is to be considered the best of the brāhmaṇas and a learned paṇḍita.”
Similarly, the Tattva-sāgara says:
yathā kāñcanatāṁ yāti kāṁsyaṁ rasa-vidhānataḥ
tathā dīkṣā-vidhānena dvijatvaṁ jāyate nṛṇām
“As bell metal is turned to gold when mixed with mercury in an alchemical process, so one who is properly trained and initiated by a bona fide spiritual master becomes a brāhmaṇa immediately.” All this evidence found in the revealed scriptures proves that according to the Vedic version, a Vaiṣṇava is never to be considered an abrāhmaṇa, or non-brāhmaṇa. A Vaiṣṇava should not be thought to belong to a lower caste even if born in a mleccha or yavana family. Because he has become a devotee of Lord Kṛṣṇa, he has become purified and has attained the stage of brāhmaṇa (dvijatvaṁ jāyate nṛṇām).
COMMENT
So previously, the sacred thread used to be awarded to persons born in Brahmin families who were trained as Brahmins, qualified as brahmans, and initiated as brahmans by the spiritual master. But Srila Bhaktisiddhanta Sarasvati Thakura began the practice of awarding the sacred thread to Vaishnavas who were not born in Brahmin families. Following the logic as stated here, the Vaishnava is already more than a Brahmin. A Vaishnava means a real Vaishnava is transcendentally situated above the material modes of nature, whereas someone who is only a Brahmin is in the material mode of goodness, still in the material world. Whereas The Vaishnava is beyond the material modes of nature and more than a brahman. But because people have respect for brahmans, they don’t actually know the position of Vaishnavas. Bhaktisiddhanta Sarasvati did not want them to commit offenses against Vaishnavas by thinking that because they were not brahmans, they were less than brahmans. So he introduced the sacred thread for Vaishnavas not born in Brahmin families, and Srila Prabhupada continued the practice. Because if people minimize the value of Vaishnavas, they commit offense and then they cannot make advancement in devotional service.
TEXT 30
Kālidāsa again offered his obeisances to Jhaḍu Ṭhākura and asked his permission to go. The saint Jhaḍu Ṭhākura followed him as he left.
TEXT 31
After bidding farewell to Kālidāsa, Jhaḍu Ṭhākura returned to his home, leaving the marks of his feet plainly visible in many places.
COMMENT
What did I just read? What did I just read? Yes, yes, that is correct, but I read three sentences. So what were the three sentences? I just read them about one minute ago. Okay, I will read again and then I will ask again. Now listen this time.
Kālidāsa again offered his obeisances to Jhaḍu Ṭhākura and asked his permission to go. The saint Jhaḍu Ṭhākura followed him as he left. After bidding farewell to Kālidāsa, Jhaḍu Ṭhākura returned to his home, leaving the marks of his feet plainly visible in many places.
Bhakta ravi, what did I just read?
Kālidāsa again offered his obeisances to Jhaḍu Ṭhākura Then he asked permission to leave. And who followed who? Yes, then Jhaḍu Ṭhākura followed Kālidāsa. Then after leaving Kālidāsa, he went back home and left his footprints in the sand.
Now, in the context of what we have been reading and discussing, what is the significance of the fact that Kālidāsa offered obeisances to Jhaḍu Ṭhākura? Anyone?
[Unintelligent: 01:00:50]
Yes, in other words, Kālidāsa was born as a Brahmin, and Jhaḍu Ṭhākura was born in a lower caste. So Kalidas quoted some verses about the exalted position of Vaishnavas, and Jhaḍu Ṭhākura accepted the statements of the scriptures but said.
Dive into the Nectar
Books by Giriraj Swami

Dancing White Elephants
Traveling with Srila Prabhupada in India, August 1970-March 1972

I'll Build You a Temple
The epic story of challenge and triumph in the founding of the Juhu temple.

Watering the Seed
Anecdotes from the pastimes and teachings of Srila Prabhupada.

Many Moons
A recollection and celebration of the wonderful qualities, and activities of devotees who have left our vision

Life's Final Exam
Death and Dying from the Vedic Perspective
Deepen Your Spiritual Journey
Weekly Inspiration from Giriraj Swami
Sign up to receive weekly emails with exclusive content from Giriraj Swami, including recent lectures, excerpts from upcoming books, and announcements about workshops and retreats. Dive deeper into Krishna consciousness and stay connected with a community of like-minded seekers on your spiritual path.

