TLC – Teachings of Lord Caitanya to Sanatana Gosvami—Part 01

March 16, 1992
Durban, South Africa

Giriraj Swami: We begin by offering our obeisances to Sri Chaitanya Mahaprabhu.

CC Madhya 20.1

vande ‘nantādbhutaiśvaryaṁ
śrī-caitanya-mahāprabhum
nīco ‘pi yat-prasādāt syād
bhakti-śāstra-pravartakaḥ

TRANSLATION

Let me offer my respectful obeisances unto Śrī Caitanya Mahāprabhu, who has unlimited, wonderful opulences. By His mercy, even a person born as the lowest of men can spread the science of devotional service.

jaya jaya śrī-caitanya jaya nityānanda

jayādvaitacandra jaya gaura-bhakta-vṛnda

TEXT 2

All glories to Lord Caitanya Mahāprabhu, Nityānanda Prabhu, Advaita Prabhu and all the devotees of Lord Caitanya!

COMMENT

After Sri Chaitanya Mahaprabhu had gone to Jagannatha Puri, He desired to visit Vrindavan. So, coming north from Orissa, He entered Bengal and halted at one place called Ramakeli. Two brothers named Dabir Khas and Sakar Malik, who were born in high-grade Hindu Brahman families but who had accepted posts in the Mohamadan government of Nawab Hussain Shah came to Him incognito to surrender themselves unto Him. Lord Chaitanya accepted the two brothers. And changed their names to Sanatana Gosvami and Rupa Gosvami. The two brothers were Chief Minister and Finance Minister, respectively. And Sanatana Gosvami, being the Chief Minister or Prime Minister, was very much required by Nawab Hussain Shah. Rupa Gosvami was able to escape and go to Vrindavan. However, Sanatana Gosvami took sick leave and stayed at home studying Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam in the association of learned Vaishnavas. But the king heard reports that Sanatana Gosvami was not actually sick. So one day, he personally went to the place of Sanatana Gosvami, and he saw Sanatana Gosvami and the Vaishnavas engaged in discussing Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam. He became very angry and had Sanatana Gosvami arrested and imprisoned. But by various means, Sanatana Gosvami escaped from the prison and started on the way to Vrindavan to join Rupa Gosvami. In between, Rupa Gosvami had already left Vrindavan, and Sanatana Gosvami also wanted to meet Sri Chaitanya Mahaprabhu. And actually, he met Him in Varanasi. And there, Lord Chaitanya instructed him in the science of devotional service.

Sanatana Gosvami was humility personified, and even when he met Lord Chaitanya and inquired from Him, he did so with great humility. Taking some straw between his teeth and prostrating himself at Mahaprabhu’s feet. He said that, “In ordinary affairs, people consider me to be very learned, but the fact is I am so learned that I do not even know who I am. I do not even know what is my duty in life, what is my goal in life. I am such a pundit, and I am so foolish that when people call me a pundit, I accept it.” Then Sanatana Gosvami inquired, “key ami, who am I? Why am I suffering the threefold miseries of material existence? What is my duty? What is the goal of life? And what is the means to attain the goal?” He asked so many questions to Lord Chaitanya, and Lord Chaitanya replied to all of them. He explained the constitutional position of the living entity, that Krishna has three energies: the spiritual energy, the marginal energy, and the material energy. And the living entity belongs to the marginal energy. He is actually spiritual, but because he may come under the influence of the material energy or the spiritual energy, he is called marginal. But the constitutional position of the living entity is he is the eternal servant of Krishna. And the reason he suffers the threefold miseries of material existence is because he has forgotten his eternal relationship with Krishna.

The goal of life is to develop love of God, to revive our eternal relationship with Krishna. And the process by which we develop love of God is devotional service. So, in brief, Lord Chaitanya answered the questions of Sanatana Gosvami. And then, He told one story about an astrologer named Sarvajna. Sarvajna came to the home of one poor man and he said to the poor man, “My dear friend, you are suffering in poverty, but don’t you know that your father was a very rich man? Did he not tell you about his great treasure before he left?” The poor man said, “No, I do not know.” Then Sarvajna said, “Yes, he was a rich man, and he left a great treasure for you. All you have to do is find the treasure, and you will become rich. All  the miseries of poverty will go away.” Now, knowing about his connection with the treasure was important for the poor man, but it was not sufficient to gain him the treasure. He had to know how to get the treasure. Then Sarvajna said, “The treasure is buried here. “But you should not dig on the southern side because if you dig on the southern side, so many wasps and drones will come and sting you. And do not dig on the western side, because on the western side there is one yaksha, like ghost, and he will disturb you in so many ways. And do not dig on the northern side, because on the northern side there is one black snake who will swallow you. But if you dig on the eastern side, very quickly, you will touch the treasure.”

There are various processes mentioned in Vedic literatures. But the only process that can deliver Krishna and love of Krishna is bhakti. So, digging on the eastern side means engaging in devotional service. Digging on the southern side means engaging in fruitive activities or karma-kāṇḍa. When one engages in fruitive activities, he enjoys and suffers so many reactions that are compared to the stings of wasps and drones. If he engages in mental speculation, his mind is disturbed, just like one’s mind is disturbed when one is possessed by some ghost. And one can engage in yoga also, with the idea of merging into impersonal Brahman. And merging into impersonal Brahman is compared to being swallowed by a snake. So, we have to give up all other processes except the process of pure devotional service. And if we accept the process of pure devotional service, very quickly we will attain the treasure of love of Godhead. So, just as when a poor man gets a treasure, he enjoys so many things and is automatically relieved of all poverty. Similarly, when a devotee achieves love of Krishna, he automatically relishes transcendental pleasure and is liberated from material bondage.

So, the story of Sarvajna and the poor man illustrates the three subjects described in the Vedic literatures. Hearing of his connection with the treasure is sambandha, which is compared to hearing of our relationship with God. Hearing of the means by which he could obtain the treasure is abhidheya, or the method by which we can attain the love of God. And actually, getting the treasure is prayojana, or the goal of life, which is kṛṣṇa-prema. So, Lord Chaitanya explained in more detail about sambandha. And then, in the twenty-second chapter of the Madhya-līlā, He explained about abhidheya or the process of devotional service. So, we hope that the devotees here are aware of the fact that they are the eternal servants of Krishna and are ready to begin or have already begun the process of devotional service. So, here in the course, we will concentrate on Chapter Twenty-two, and you will get the copy tomorrow, which deals with the subject of devotional service.

Before we continue the discussion of devotional service, we have to know what is the definition of pure devotional service. So, in Chapter Nineteen, Lord Chaitanya has given the definition of devotional service to Rupa Gosvami. Actually, the verse which is mentioned in Caitanya-caritāmṛta is found in Bhakti-rasāmṛta-sindhu, and the verse is the main verse in Bhakti-rasāmṛta-sindhu, because it gives the definition of pure devotional service, and the whole book is about pure devotional service. And what we are going to discuss also is only pure devotional service. So, we must know this definition very well. And we should learn the Sanskrit also. At the end of the five lectures, there will be an examination, and you will definitely be required to know the Sanskrit and English definition of pure devotional service.

So, you have the paper with the definition. Did they get it? Are you going to distribute it?

anyābhilāṣitā-śūnyaṁ
jñāna-karmādy-anāvṛtam
ānukūlyena kṛṣṇānu-
śīlanaṁ bhaktir uttamā

So, anyābhilāṣitā means  any other desire, and śūnyaṁ means should be nil. So, pure devotional service is without any other desires, any material desire. Any desire other than pure devotional service is material. jñāna-karmādy-anāvṛtam, it should not be covered by impersonal speculation, fruitive activity, or any other processes like tapasya, yoga, Sankhya, and so on. Ānukūlyena, kṛṣṇānu-śīlanam; ānukūlyena means it should be favorable to Krishna’s pleasure, and anuśīlanaṁ means, it should be continuous cultivation or continuous service. bhaktir uttamā, this is first-class devotional service. So, let us take each word more deeply. kṛṣṇā here kṛṣṇā means Krishna, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, as well as the various expansions of Krishna, and the pure devotees of Krishna also. So our devotional service must be in relation to Krishna, Krishna’s name, Krishna’s form, Krishna’s qualities, Krishna’s pastimes, Krishna’s paraphernalia, Krishna’s devotees and so on.

Srila Rupa Gosvami says, all of the items of devotional service that can be rendered in relation to Krishna can also be rendered in relation to Krishna’s devotees. Anuśīlanaṁ means cultivation. Cultivation means activity. So the activity which is performed in relation to Krishna may be performed with the body, with the mind, or with the words. In pure devotional service, all of the faculties of the person, namely mental, vocal, and sensual, should be engaged in the service of Krishna. With our senses, we can clean the temple of Krishna, cook for Krishna, offer the ārati to Krishna, and so on. With our words, we can chant the holy name of Krishna and preach the message of Krishna. And with our minds, we can remember the pastimes of Krishna, remember the instructions of Krishna, and think of how to serve Krishna nicely, how to spread the saṅkīrtana movement. Ānukūlyena means that the service should be favorable, as Krishna wants. We should serve Krishna as Krishna wants. Just like Krishna says, patraṁ puṣpaṁ phalaṁ toyaṁ yo me bhaktyā prayacchati, that if we offer Him with love and devotion a leaf, a fruit, a flower, or some water, He will accept it. We cannot offer Krishna meat, fish, eggs, or alcohol because He doesn’t ask for that. So we have to offer Krishna what He wants.

Now, let us take some examples to understand more clearly. One time, Mother Yasoda was feeding baby Krishna with her breast milk. Then the milk on the fire began to boil over. Mother Yasoda set aside baby Krishna to tend to the milk on the fire, but baby Krishna wasn’t satisfied by drinking Mother Yasoda’s milk yet, and He became very angry and frustrated when she set Him aside. His eyes became red, tears flowed from His eyes, and He began to weep. Now, Mother Yasoda set aside Krishna. Krishna was very upset that she did so, and apparently, she considered the milk to be more important than Krishna. Instead of taking care of Krishna, she was taking care of the milk on the fire. So, is this devotional service? What do you think? Is this favorable? Well, apparently, Mother Yasoda’s action was not favorable because Krishna was not pleased. In fact, Krishna was very upset. But if we look more closely, we will see why did Yasoda set aside Krishna to tend to the milk on the fire? Only for Krishna’s service. Because the milk on the fire was also meant for Krishna. So her attitude was favorable towards Krishna. She wanted to please Krishna by boiling the milk on the fire. And although outwardly, Krishna appeared to be upset, but inwardly, He was actually pleased. He can never be displeased with Mother Yasoda, but only for the sake of pastimes, He appeared to be displeased. So certainly, Mother Yasoda was engaged in devotional service. In fact, the milk on the fire is also devoted to Krishna because in the spiritual world, everything is conscious and full of love for Krishna. So the milk on the fire thought that if Krishna gets satisfied by drinking the milk from Yasoda’s breast, then I won’t get the chance to serve Krishna. But if I boil over, then Yasoda will set aside Krishna and come to me, and then in the end, I will also get the chance to serve Krishna. So serving Krishna’s devotee or paraphernalia is as good or better than trying to serve Krishna directly.

We have the example of Maharaja Pratāparudra, who wanted to meet Lord Chaitanya, but because he was a king and Lord Chaitanya was a sannyasi, He would not meet him at first. So the devotees arranged to deliver a piece of Lord Chaitanya’s cloth to the king, and when the king got the cloth, he began to worship it. And when Lord Chaitanya heard the news, He was pleased and He quoted the verse,

ārādhanānāṁ sarveṣāṁ
viṣṇor ārādhanaṁ param
tasmāt parataraṁ
devi
tadīyānāṁ samarcanam

That of all types of worship, the worship of Vishnu is the highest, but even higher than the worship of Vishnu is the worship of things related to Vishnu. So he worshiped Lord Chaitanya’s cloth as Lord Chaitanya Himself. When Srila Prabhupada went to the West, all the devotees could see that he was constantly engaged in serving Krishna, chanting about Krishna, speaking about Krishna, engaging devotees in Krishna’s service. But one day, Srila Prabhupada just stood by the window and was looking out the window at the street, and the devotees were surprised. They never expected to see Srila Prabhupada just looking out the window. But then Srila Prabhupada explained the reason. He said he wanted to have Ratha-yatra, and he was looking at the different types of trucks on the street so he could see which type of truck would be suitable. So he wasn’t spacing out, but he was seeing things in relation to Krishna’s service. So not material.

Now we will take another example. That Krishna, in the mood of chivalry, likes to fight. So by fighting with Kamsa, Shisupala and about eighteen other demons who tried to attack and kill Krishna, Krishna derived pleasure. So can we say that Kamsa was engaged in devotional service? So Kamsa was a devotee? No, Kamsa was not engaged in devotional service because his attitude towards Krishna was not favorable. In fact, his attitude towards Krishna was inimical; he wanted to kill Krishna. He was always absorbed in Krishna in fear, and he wanted to kill Krishna. Similarly, Shishupal was always absorbed in thoughts of Krishna in envy, and he also wanted to kill Krishna. So the word “favorable” has two elements: one is that the devotee’s mood should be favorable to pleasing Krishna, and two, Krishna should actually be pleased. So even though Krishna was pleased to fight with the demons, but because the mood of the demons was not favorable to Krishna’s pleasure, so we cannot accept their activities as bhakti. So the attitude should be favorable, and the results should also be favorable. Krishna should actually be pleased. One time also, the devotees in New York wanted to buy a building, and they sought to buy the building from one man named Mr. Price. But Mr. Price was a rascal, and he just wanted to cheat the devotees, take the money and cheat them. And actually, Srila Prabhupada had warned the devotees not to give any money to the man unless there was a proper agreement. But he bewildered them and took all the money that the devotees had, five thousand dollars, and nothing—no building, no agreement, nothing.

So finally, Srila Prabhupada personally came to New York to try to deal with the situation and get back the money. So one time, Mr. Price phoned, and Srila Prabhupada answered the phone, and he very graciously said, “Oh, Mr. Price, I am always thinking of you. I am so glad you phoned me.” So afterwards, the devotee asked Srila Prabhupada, “Is that true that you are always thinking of Mr. Price?” And Srila Prabhupada said, “Yes, just like Kamsa was always thinking of Krishna.” So that is Krishna consciousness, but not favorable, so it is not bhakti. Now anyābhilāṣitā-śūnyaṁ, there should be no other desire but we are engaging in sādhana-bhakti in order to achieve prema-bhakti. So, is that an extraneous desire? Is that against the principles of bhakti. To engage in sādhana-bhakti in order to achieve prema-bhakti, is that against uttamā-bhakti? No, because why do we want prema-bhakti? So that we can serve Krishna better. We desire bhakti. So anyābhilāṣitā-śūnyaṁ, there should be no desire except for bhakti, but if one desires bhāva-bhakti or prema-bhakti, higher stages of bhakti, that is not against bhakti.

Now, some devotee may not be accustomed to pray for material things. Actually, a pure devotee will never pray for material things. But suddenly, some evil person may appear with a knife to attack the devotee and kill him, and the devotee will pray to Krishna, “Please save me.” Now, such a prayer, although it is not correct in one sense, but such a prayer is not an impediment to pure devotional service because the devotee is not in the habit of praying for material protection or anything. But only in an extreme situation, in a moment of panic, the devotee may pray to Krishna for protection, material protection. But as soon as the crisis is over and the devotee comes to normal consciousness, he won’t pray to Krishna for anything material. So, in some extreme crisis of life and death, if the devotee in the state of extreme anxiety prays to the Lord for protection, but if he is not accustomed to praying to the Lord for material things, then it is not an impediment to bhakti. He should go on with bhakti, and gradually, when he realizes his actual identity, then he won’t feel such anxiety even when threatened with death.

Jñāna-karmādy-anāvṛtam. Here, jnana refers to mental speculation that leads to impersonal conclusions that cover bhakti. So, jnana actually means to know the difference between matter and spirit. So from jnana, one can come to different conclusions. One conclusion can be that one wants to merge and become one with impersonal Brahman. And another conclusion is that one engages in the service of the Lord. So here, only knowledge which leads to another conclusion besides devotional service should be rejected. And karma means activities. So, worshiping the deity, for example, as part of the process of devotional service, does not cover bhakti. But worshiping the deity or doing sacrifices for material gains, as part of the system of karma-kāṇḍa, is against bhakti. There are so many, activities mentioned in the karma-kāṇḍa sections of the Vedic literatures, which are meant for material elevation for oneself, for one’s family, for one’s forefathers, and so on. So here, the question may be raised that, “I come from a good Hindu family, and my father dies, and according to Vedic tradition, or karma-kāṇḍa, I should perform some last rites, some funeral ceremony.” So the question is, should I do it? Will it be against bhakti if I do it?

Devotee: [Unintelligible 00:48:15]

Giriraj Swami: It is not for Krishna, so we should not do it. Any other ideas?

Devotee: [Unintelligible 00:48:40]

Giriraj Swami: He says that if we don’t do it, then the other family members may become inimical. So if we do it, it would not be against bhakti.

Correct. Although the funeral rites might be part of karma-kāṇḍa, but if we don’t do the funeral rites, then the family members may criticize. So in order to keep the family members favorable, we can do it, and it is not against bhakti. But if we think that if I don’t do it, I am guilty of some sin, or if we think that if I do it, I will get some good karma that will help me in bhakti, that is against bhakti. In other words, if we think that by not doing it, I will lose, or by doing it, I will gain, that is against bhakti. But if we understand that bhakti is independent of karma and jnana, that nothing I can do of karma or jnana will help me in bhakti, but to the contrary, by mixing karma and jnana with bhakti, bhakti is weakened. But if I don’t do it, people will criticize, and for the sake of preaching, I do it, then it is not against bhakti.

Just like one devotee asked Srila Prabhupada that if a devotee sees a man drowning in a river, should he save him? Srila Prabhupada said that actually, we have nothing to do with the karma of other people because trying to deal with the karma of other people is also karma. If someone is suffering the results of past karma, and I try to relieve the suffering by material means, that is another karma. Srila Prabhupada replied that actually, we have nothing to do to interfere with other people’s karma. But if we don’t save him, then people will criticize that, “Oh, he is a devotee; he could have saved the man, but he didn’t save him. What kind of a devotee is he?” So, there is a consideration in devotional service of popular opinion or sentiment that to avoid criticism, we may do something to cater to popular sentiment, even though ordinarily we would not do it as part of devotional service. This is called lokavichar, taking into consideration popular sentiment.

One time in Australia, several ladies were trapped in the top floor of a burning building. And on the ground beneath the building, the devotees were working on the Ratha cart. So when they saw the ladies surrounded by flames at the window at the top of the building, they held out the cloth for the canopy and told them to jump. So they jumped, and they were saved. So then, the next day, all the newspapers carried big articles and photos and headlines, how the devotees had saved the ladies. And, they were especially impressed that they used the sacred cloth from the chariot. So then, Srila Prabhupada had his secretary, cut out the articles and send them to me in Bombay, with the instruction that I should meet all big men in Bombay and show them the cutting, and tell them that Krishna consciousness is rendering the best welfare service to humanity, both materially and spiritually.

So, to avoid criticism, we may do something which is not ordinarily in the category of bhakti, but for the sake of popular opinion, so that they don’t become inimical, and so that we will be able to preach to them, we can do. So, we will just give one more example. Lord Chaitanya had one devotee named Mukunda dasa, who was a court physician to the Muhammadan king. So once, the Muhammadan king was sitting on a very high platform with Mukunda dasa, and one attendant came to fan the king with peacock fans. When Mukunda saw the peacock fan, he went into ecstasy and fainted and fell from the platform, and he could have died. The king himself came down from the platform to see him. Now, is this in the category of devotional service? Does this fit in the definition of bhakti? Yes, it does. Although for devotees in the stage of practice, anuśīlanaṁ means activities performed with the body, mind, and words, but advanced devotees who are in the stage of ecstasy, they experience things which are beyond body, mind, and words. Their ecstasy, bhāva, is completely transcendental. But the activities of bhāva, or the ecstasies of bhāva in the purified soul are also included in anuśīlanaṁ, although they are beyond body, mind, and words. So, this is the definition of bhakti, and we should know the definition, so we can identify pure devotional service, and so we can identify things that are against pure devotional service.

So, we will end here and see if there are any questions.

Devotee: [Unintelligible 00:59:14]

Giriraj Swami: Do you know the answer? Good question. Is it possible to please Krishna in a chivalrous mood without being unfavorable towards Him, like Kamsa was unfavorable?

So, following the instructions of Lord Chaitanya, Rupa Gosvami has analyzed, on the basis of Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam, twelve rasas; five are direct, favorable, and seven are indirect, unfavorable. So, direct one are śānta-rasa, dāsya-rasa, sākhya-rasa, vātsalya-rasa, and mādhurya-rasa, they are primary rasas. But there are also seven other rasas which are not favorable as such. There is hāsya-rasa; hāsya-rasa means laughing. Now, if you see someone and laugh at him, it is not favorable. But if you love the person, like a parent loves the child, and then laugh at him, then it is not unfavorable. When the laughter is mixed with the primary relationship of parental love, then it is not unfavorable.

So, actually, hāsya-rasa is very compatible with mādhurya-rasa, with vātsalya-rasa, and with sākhya-rasa. But it is not compatible with dāsya-rasa. The servant cannot laugh at the master. But amongst the cowherd boys, there is so much laughter. And Krishna’s parents, they also laugh at Krishna when He grabs hold of the tail of the cow, and the cow starts to run in the mud, and Krishna gets dragged in the mud; they laugh. 

The publisher assumes no responsibility for any errors or omissions in the content of the transcriptions provided on the site. The information contained in these transcribed lectures has not been exhaustively edited and is provided on an "as-is" basis with no guarantees of accuracy.
Dive into the Nectar

Books by Giriraj Swami

Deepen Your Spiritual Journey

Weekly Inspiration from Giriraj Swami

Sign up to receive weekly emails with exclusive content from Giriraj Swami, including recent lectures, excerpts from upcoming books, and announcements about workshops and retreats. Dive deeper into Krishna consciousness and stay connected with a community of like-minded seekers on your spiritual path.

Name(Required)