SB 2.1.34–36 – One’s Desires Develop by Association

September 16, 1998
Spain

Giriraj Swami: 

oṁ namo bhagavate vāsudevāya

oṁ namo bhagavate vāsudevāya

oṁ namo bhagavate vāsudevāya

Reading from Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam, Canto Two, Chapter One, “The First Step in God Realization,” Text Thirty-Four.

TEXT 34

O best amongst the Kurus, the clouds which carry water are the hairs on His head, the terminations of days or nights are His dress, and the supreme cause of material creation is His intelligence. His mind is the moon, the reservoir of all changes.

COMMENT

There is no purport, so we’ll go to Text Thirty-Five.

TEXT 35

The principle of matter [mahat-tattva] is the consciousness of the omnipresent Lord, as asserted by the experts, and Rudradeva is His ego. The horse, mule, camel and elephant are His nails, and wild animals and all quadrupeds are situated in the belt zone of the Lord.

COMMENT

Again, there is no purport, so we’ll proceed to Text Thirty-Six.

TEXT 36

vayāṁsi tad-vyākaraṇaṁ vicitraṁ
manur manīṣā manujo nivāsaḥ
gandharva-vidyādhara-cāraṇāpsaraḥ
svara-smṛtīr asurānīka-vīryaḥ

TRANSLATION

Varieties of birds are indications of His masterful artistic sense. Manu, the father of mankind, is the emblem of His standard intelligence, and humanity is His residence. The celestial species of human beings, like the Gandharvas, Vidyādharas, Cāraṇas and angels, all represent His musical rhythm, and the demoniac soldiers are representations of His wonderful prowess.

PURPORT by Srila Prabhupada

The aesthetic sense of the Lord is manifested in the artistic, colorful creation of varieties of birds like the peacock, parrot and cuckoo. The celestial species of human beings, like the Gandharvas and Vidyādharas, can sing wonderfully and can entice even the minds of the heavenly demigods. Their musical rhythm represents the musical sense of the Lord.

COMMENT

So, the Lord is the origin of everything. Whatever we experience in the material world exists originally in Lord Krishna in the spiritual world. So, if anyone has a musical sense in the material world, he is getting the musical sense, ultimately, from the Supreme Lord. And therefore, the musical rhythms of the higher beings like Gandharvas and Vidyādharas are representations of the musical sense of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. So, whenever we find some musical talent, we should know that the origin is the Lord, and the musical talent may be cultivated from the previous lifetime.

The famous example is Mozart. When Mozart was seven years old, he was composing a symphony, which was classic. He had no chance to learn so much music in his present life. So, musical knowledge was the product of the previous life. Srila Prabhupada even said that John Lennon had been a musician in Calcutta in his previous life. So, all extraordinary abilities are representations of the abilities of the Lord. And in the conception of the universal form, one conceives of the musical rhythm of the celestial beings as the musical sense of the Lord.

PURPORT (continued)

How then can He be impersonal? His musical taste, artistic sense and standard intelligence, which is never fallible, are different signs of His supreme personality.

COMMENT

So, we may see some work of art in the material world, and we know some person must have made it. We hear some musical composition in the material world, and we know some person must have created it. Similarly, we read some intelligent book, and we know some person must have written it. Musical taste, artistic sense, intelligent writing come from a person. So, since musical rhythm and artistic beauty and intelligent words emanate from the Absolute Truth, how can the Absolute Truth be impersonal? The Absolute Truth is personal. The Absolute Truth is Krishna.

PURPORT (continued)

The Manu-saṁhitā is the standard lawbook for humanity, and every human being is advised to follow this great book of social knowledge.

COMMENT

So, Manu-saṁhitā is the law book for mankind. So, human society should be regulated by the laws of Manu. From Manu-saṁhitā, we learn about who is guilty in the killing of animals, and Manu-saṁhitā explains that many persons are implicated in this sin of meat eating. The person who raises the animal for slaughter, the person who slaughters the animal, and the person who transports the meat, sells the meat, the person who cooks the meat, and the person who eats the meat. All are considered culpable. Just like if there is a conspiracy to murder a person. It’s not just the person that fires the bullet who is culpable. The person who conceived of the plan, the person who drove the car, all the people involved in the conspiracy are considered responsible.

Once, the editor of Back to Godhead had the idea of publishing an article about slaughterhouses and the horrors of slaughterhouses. A promoter of vegetarianism produced a film, which really showed the horrors of slaughterhouses. Anyone who saw the film became vegetarian. Anyone who actually sees the animals can understand that the animals are conscious. Some years ago, there was a film made in America called Babe, and the hero of the movie was Babe, it was a pig, and all the other main characters were farm animals. So, the cameraman won the Academy Award for cinematography, and he was interviewed after he won the Academy Award. He said that by making the film, he could understand that the animals were persons, and he became vegetarian.

And children, if they are given to understand the fact that the meat on the table is the flesh of animals, they won’t want to eat it. Long ago, the children in America were turning away from eating meat. So, the demons are so clever. They ran an advertising campaign showing hamburgers growing on trees, and they showed a little child walking through the groves of trees, picking hamburgers from the trees. They want to cover the intelligence of the consumers, what they are actually doing when they consume flesh.

So, the editor of Back to Godhead wanted to run an article which showed the horrors of slaughterhouses. But Srila Prabhupada said no. He said, “If you run an article about slaughterhouses, then the butchers or the people who work in the slaughterhouses will feel bad. And why should you single out the butchers? The consumers are as guilty as the butchers who slaughter the animals. Why single out the butchers? The people who sell the meat, the people who cook the meat, the people who eat the meat, are fully responsible.”

So, we get such important instructions from Manu-saṁhitā. Another important instruction from Manu-saṁhitā concerns capital punishment. Manu-saṁhitā recommends that if a person commits a murder, he should be killed. The execution of the murderer is beneficial for the murderer. The present life is spoiled because in the present life he is a murderer, and the next life is also spoiled because he still has to suffer the sinful reaction for the murder. But if the murderer is awarded capital punishment, then the present life is finished. So, the murderer actually benefits from capital punishment.

In the name of compassion and liberality, modern leaders who are quite ignorant of the laws of God, who are quite ignorant of Manu-saṁhitā, they make agitation to stop capital punishment. But actually, capital punishment is best for murderers. Of course, sometimes an innocent person may be judged guilty. That’s another problem. But otherwise, capital punishment is in the best interest of the murderer.

So, we need to take guidance from standard books of authority. We cannot rule by mental speculation or live according to our own whimsies and expect to be peaceful and happy. Vedic literature is meant to give us direction on how to live and how to run the affairs of the state and be peaceful and happy. And we see that because in the modern world, people do not take direction from the Vedic scriptures, everyone is disturbed, everyone is full of anxiety, everyone is afflicted by miseries, practically no one is peaceful or happy.

PURPORT (continued)

Human society is the residential quarters for the Lord. This means that the human being is meant for God realization and association with God. This life is a chance for the conditioned soul to regain his eternal God consciousness and thus fulfill the mission of life.

COMMENT

So here, the Bhāgavatam says manīṣā manujo nivāsaḥ, that the minds of the human beings are the residential place for the Lord. In other words, the Lord is meant to live in the midst of human beings, which means that human beings are meant to invoke the presence of the Lord. There are nine processes of devotional service. In such processes of devotional service, we get the association of the Lord, especially the process of hearing and chanting the glories of the Lord. Lord Krishna says nāhaṁ tiṣṭhāmi vaikuṇṭhe, “I do not reside in Vaikuntha,” yogināṁ vā hṛdaye ca, “Nor do I live in the hearts of the yogis, but I am there wherever My devotees are chanting My glories.” So, we remain in constant contact with the Lord.

To be in the association of the Lord is called Bhagavat saṅga. Devotees are called Bhagavat sangi because they are always in the association of the Lord. Srila Prabhupada recommends that we should associate with devotees, with the words, Bhagavat sangi saṅga, we should associate with persons who are associated with the Lord.

So, the Bhāgavatam explains that by associating with persons who are associated with the Lord, even for a moment, one gets such a benefit as cannot be compared to heavenly enjoyment or liberation, what to speak of worldly pleasures, which are meant for those who are about to die. Things which have common features can be compared. Someone’s association with a devotee or a person who is in association with the Lord cannot be compared to elevation to the heavenly planet or even liberation because the benefits are too different.

By associating with the devotee for a moment, one can get the seed of devotional service, and by regularly associating with devotees, chanting and hearing in the association of devotees, one waters the seed. And when the seed grows into a full-fledged plant and bears the fruit of love of God, one enjoys unlimited spiritual bliss. But the happiness one gets from heavenly pleasures is temporary; the happiness one gets from love of God is eternal. There is no comparison between the two.

Similarly, the happiness one gets from impersonal liberation is so insignificant compared to the happiness of love of God, one cannot even compare the two. So, the value of the association of devotees cannot be measured because the happiness one gets from pure devotional service cannot be compared to any happiness in the material world or even in the spiritual sky. So, we stay in the association of the Lord or stay in the association of devotees.

PURPORT (continued)

Mahārāja Prahlāda is the right type of representative of the Lord in the family of asuras.

COMMENT

Kashyapa Muni had two wives; Diti and Aditi. Diti approached her husband for sex at an inauspicious time. Because her husband agreed, Diti gave birth to demons, and therefore, the demons are called Daityas. On the other hand, Aditi had sex life according to religious principles with Kashyapa Muni, and she gave birth to demigods, to devotees, and for some special austerities she performed, she gave birth to the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Kapiladeva.

But although the Daityas are by nature demons, within the family of the demons, some individuals can become devotees. Prominent among the devotees in the family of demons is Prahlada Maharaja. Also, Lord Krishna says that of Daityas, he is the devoted Prahlada. So, there is a chance for everyone to become Krishna conscious, no matter what type of family he takes birth in. Anyone can become a devotee by the mercy of the Lord through the association of the Lord and His devotees.

I don’t know if I should mention, but Srila Prabhupada’s eldest son was extremely clever and intelligent. He did not become a devotee. So once, Srila Prabhupada’s son met one of Srila Prabhupada’s disciples, and he said, “My father is a great sage like Kashyapa Muni, but I am a demon. And your fathers are demons like Hiraṇyakaśipu, but you are devotees like Prahlada.” So, even someone born of a devoted father can become a demon, and someone born of a demonic father can become a devotee. Everything depends on our choice, it depends on our association.

But we can choose our association. Devotees, we can become devotees. We choose to associate with materialistic persons, we become materialistic. One’s desires develop by association with servants of Krishna, we can develop the desire to serve Krishna. We associate with servants of the senses; we develop a desire for sense gratification. Everyone in every part of the world, in every type of family and background, has the chance to become a devotee if you so desire.

PURPORT (continued)

None of the living beings is away from the Lord’s gigantic body. Each and every one has a particular duty in relation to the supreme body. Disruption in the matter of discharging the specific duty assigned to each and every living being is the cause of disharmony between one living being and another, but when the relation is reestablished in relation with the Supreme Lord, there is complete unity between all living beings, even up to the limit of the wild animals and human society.

COMMENT

So, every living entity has some place in the Lord’s universal form to the Lord’s transcendental service. All living entities work in harmony with each other. There are different parts of the body which have different functions. The stomach has its function, the arms have their function, the head has its function. But they all work in harmony for the benefit of the body. Similarly, all living beings are part and parcel of the universal form of the Lord. They are meant to work in harmony for the interest of the Lord.

Srila Prabhupada makes a very striking statement. When the relation is re-established in relation with the Supreme Lord. In other words, when the relation between living beings is reestablished in relation with the Supreme Lord, there is complete unity between all living beings, even up to the limit of the wild animals and human society. Even wild animals and human beings who are placed here by Srila Prabhupada in the same category, even human beings and wild animals can learn to live harmoniously if they become Krishna conscious and act in their proper positions in Krishna’s service.

Dharmeṇa hīna paśubhiḥ samāna, without religious duties, a human being is no better than an animal, and actually, the human beings become worse than animals. Human beings kill their own children in the womb, sometimes even outside the womb. But the wild animals won’t kill their offspring in the womb. So, the human beings, without God consciousness, become worse than the animals.

Once, I visited the zoo in Johannesburg, and different sections were allotted to different types of animals. And before entering the area, one could read panels with pictures of the different species and descriptions of the different species. So, before we went into the area with the most ferocious animals, we saw the panels. One for lion, one for tiger, one for jaguar, one for leopard. And on the last panel was the world’s most dangerous animal. And under the caption was a mirror. And you see the world’s most dangerous animal, it’s us. We are more dangerous than the most ferocious lions, tigers, and cheetahs. Wild animals and human beings can learn to live in harmony in Krishna consciousness.

PURPORT (continued)

Lord Caitanya Mahāprabhu displayed this living unity in the jungle of Madhya Pradesh, where even the tigers, elephants and many other ferocious animals perfectly cooperated in glorifying the Supreme Lord. That is the way to peace and amity all over the world.

COMMENT

What is the way to peace and amity all over the world? Cooperating to glorify the Supreme Lord. Congregational chanting of the holy names and cooperative spreading of the chanting of the holy name, Hare Krishna, Hare Krishna, Krishna Krishna, Hare Hare / Hare Rama, Hare Rama, Rama Rama, Hare Hare. Are there any questions or comments?

“How can someone whose consciousness was so contaminated that he could kill another human being become so purified by capital punishment that he can take birth among pious living entities?”

There are different types of atonement mentioned in the Vedic scriptures, and the result of such atonement is that the person becomes free from sinful reactions. The Nectar of Devotion explains that sinful reactions mature in different stages. The reaction begins in the form of a seed. So, different stages of sinful reactions are eradicated one after the other by devotional service, and they are eradicated permanently. Like taking bath in sacred rivers, going to holy places, and so on.

Prāyaścitta, by which one becomes temporarily relieved of the sinful reactions. Free from the sinful reactions, one may still have the desire to commit sin. Therefore, the benefit of such atonement is temporary. Unless one gets the association of devotees, because the person underwent the atonement of capital punishment, he is freed from sinful reactions to the extent that he can take birth in the place of pious living entities. And hopefully, by staying in the association of pious living entities, he won’t go back to the sinful activities of the previous life, for the living entity has minute independence. By chance, he may misuse his independence. If they take the association, there is every chance that the living entity will remain pious.

Question: [Unintelligible 00:34:34].

Giriraj Swami: He asked if by devotional service, one can atone for the sin of killing someone. The answer is yes. In his earlier life, Valmiki was a murderer, a plunderer, he committed all sorts of sins. But by indirectly chanting the holy name of Rama, he became so purified that he became a great devotee by the mercy of Narada. Any other questions or comments?

Question: [Unintelligible 00:35:48].

Giriraj Swami: Not usually. Maya means energy. Maya also means illusion. Although we might consider the material energy to refer to the material objects and maya to refer to the bewildering potency that makes us identify with the material objects, maya can also be used in the sense of referring to the material objects themselves, material energy. But what you said is also true. Maya can be used in the sense of the potency which bewilders the living entities. Maya refers to the material energy itself.

Thank you very much. All glories to Srila Prabhupada. Hare Krishna.

The publisher assumes no responsibility for any errors or omissions in the content of the transcriptions provided on the site. The information contained in these transcribed lectures has not been exhaustively edited and is provided on an "as-is" basis with no guarantees of accuracy.
Dive into the Nectar

Books by Giriraj Swami

Deepen Your Spiritual Journey

Weekly Inspiration from Giriraj Swami

Sign up to receive weekly emails with exclusive content from Giriraj Swami, including recent lectures, excerpts from upcoming books, and announcements about workshops and retreats. Dive deeper into Krishna consciousness and stay connected with a community of like-minded seekers on your spiritual path.

Name(Required)