Hinduism and Bioethics—A Seminar by Giriraj Swami and Dr. S. Cromwell Crawford
Houston, Texas
Krishna Kripa dasa: We are so very fortunate that we have our feature speakers today—Professor S. Cromwell Crawford—he is going to be giving us an Hindu perspective in reference to bioethics in the sense of research—and His Holiness Giriraj Maharaja who will be giving us the Vaishnava perspective on the same subject.
Professor Crawford, I will give you all the details of what he has done and what he represents and what he brings before he tells you about the bioethics and the stem cell research. Professor Crawford will speak first and then we will ask His Holiness Giriraj Maharaja to come in and speak about the Vaishnava perspective of the bioethics issue and then we will have some questions and answers.
As you would understand, today’s program will be [?] both excellent speakers in their perspective subject to come in and talk about the issue.
We ask you to pay careful attention.
Professor Cromwell Crawford, his country of origin is India, but he holds a US citizenship. He spends most of his time in the department of religion in the University of Hawaii. He is the chairman for the department of religion in the University of Hawaii. He has a double theology degree in philosophy from Berkeley, California, he has a Master of Arts in philosophy and ethics from Indiana University, and he has a bachelor degree in the Serampore University, India.
He has held so many academic positions that if I stood here and told you all about all the positions he has held, it would take probably approximately thirty minutes for me to tell you what he has done. So some of the highlights are the chairman at the Department of Religion, as I indicated to you earlier, in the University of Hawaii. He was a graduate chair in the department of religion in 1999. He was a director from 1992 to 1996 for the center for […vation?] studies [?] at University of Hawaii. He was the chairman from 1988 to 1999 for department of religion. He was the graduate chairman from ‘79 to ‘82 for the same department.
So, as you see, from where I am going here, he has held many positions in the religion field wherever he has travelled, talked, and educated many, many, many people, including the people in India.
Professional organizations that he belongs to: American Academy of Religion, Society of Christian Ethics, National Education Association, All India Ayurvedic Congress, Hindu Studies in Victoria, Canada, Jain Academic Foundation in North America, and the Royal Association of Vedic Studies amongst two and a half or three pages full of professional affiliations that he had.
He has done many, many research, he has received many, many professional awards in citation and he speaks Latin, Greek, French, Hindi, and Sanskrit. So, if you wanted to answer the professor a question in Hindi, I am sure he will be obliged to give you some answers in Hindi.
He has written many books and he has written many chapters in many books. Some of the books that he has written: Hindu Bioethics for the Twenty-first Century, The Dilemmas of Life and Death, Hindu Ethics in the North American Context, World Religions and Global Ethics in Search of Hinduism, Dr. Ram Mohan Roy, His Era and Ethics, The Evolution of Hindu Ethical Ideals. These are some of the books that he has written dating back to the 1950s and 1960s. So, he has been very active in the field that he is about to educate us on.
Without further ado, I would like to request and invite Professor Cromwell Crawford.
Professor Cromwell Crawford: I am happy to say that for many years I have had an association with the Krishna movement, very often in court cases in which the Krishna movement was involved, and I served as an “expert witness” in those cases, and as a result of that, I forged many friendships. To give you one example, about three years ago, I was India’s national lecturer, and one place that I had to give a lecture was in Bombay University. Now when the Hare Krishnas heard that I was to stay in a hotel in Bombay, they immediately cancelled the reservation, and had me come as their guest in the temple in Juhu and treated me like one of the brothers. So, I feel very honored that I have this opportunity to renew my acquaintance.
As I move among you, I have to admit I don’t have the consciousness that I am in Texas at all. I have to pinch myself to think Texas. I feel I am back home in India which is a compliment to you in recreating some of the spirit. I am not just talking about the trappings; I am talking about the spirit. And it is a warm spirit, it is a very Gandhi spirit.
I have got to tell one little Gandhi story before I launch into my talk. When I was a child living in Bombay, Gandhiji used to come to address mill workers because this was his base for getting the common people. Now there was a big maidan, big field, in front of my home, and Gandhiji, wherever he would speak, there would be thousands of people. But the fields in India in my time didn’t have any electric outlets for the PA system. So, what they would do is hunt around or scrounge around in the houses surrounding the maidan, surrounding the field, to plug in the electric outlets.
So, here I was a bacha, standing on my balcony, looking at this maddening crowd, didn’t know what it was all about. And the organizers then pointed at this electric wire and asked if I could plug it into my home. So, I am on the balcony if you can imagine in India where we had balconies. So they threw the wires over the first floor. In America this would be the second floor, but for us the first floor. They threw the wires over and I obliged, and I plugged it in, and Gandhi was able to speak with the juice that I provided. And I didn’t at that time have the feeling, but I felt it later that I had this tremendous power over the mahatma that at any time I could pull the plug on him [laughter; applause].
I want to thank Dr. Medley for being so gracious to honor me with this opportunity to share these thoughts with you.
The general theme that I will be exploring is dealing with therapy and enhancement, and I would like to frame that theme in a title which I am calling, “Is Better Always Good?” Is better always good? From one perspective, better is always good. Everyone wants better. All people want it, but I think [bad?] things carry everything to a higher level of intensity so that better very soon is transmuted into perfect. So, we think in terms of perfection. So, we want the perfect being. A few weeks ago, the time I was in. . . had as a cover story, “Designer Babies.” So, this is the perfect baby. We want perfect children; we want perfect spouses. It has been rumored that American women have the same expectations about their spouses which British women only have for their butlers. [laughter]
Nowadays nothing wrong with wanting better, as long as one recognizes that better is not always good. And here we are in the area of genetic enhancement: better. So, we are raising the question: is better in this particular medical area, is it always good?
So, the more medical side of the subject is about gene transfer for therapy or enhancement. Now I would like you to consider the following scenario: supposing gene therapy for the treatment of hormone growth deficiency, the deficiency of the growth of hormones, if there is a deficiency, [treating it?] with genetic therapy to be able to correct that deficiency, how will people respond.
I am going to give you three scenarios in which we look at three different individuals who might come to the doctor’s clinic for this type of gene enhancement therapy. Now the first case that I describe to you is young Johnny. Now Johnny has this deficiency, his body is not producing this growth hormone. He is going to grow up to the height of a dwarf. And if he could receive this genetic treatment, he will be able to grow back to the normal height that children of his age will be having. So far, for the problem, he has been taking protein injections, but these protein injections have to be administered on a daily basis and they are expensive. But if he could receive this genetic treatment then it would be less invasive, less intrusive, and certainly cheaper. So, for this young fellow, Johnny, with this deficiency of the growth, certainly the development of this genetic treatment is going to be very welcome.
Now we move to a second case. This is the case of Jimmy. Jimmy is also very short. His predicted height is going to be not more than sixty-one to sixty-three inches. But he does not have any deficiency. There is no disease in his case. The only problem with him is that his parents are short and therefore he is short. So, he wants to try to rectify the problem with the same treatment, genetic treatment.
The third case is that of Joe. Joe can be distinguished from these two boys who are short, and Joe would be seated head and shoulders taller than these two lads. Seated next to Joe is his father who is also a very tall man. But Joe feels that he needs to be taller. He has athletic ambitions, and his parents want him also to receive the same type of genetic treatment in order to be tall.
Now the question is who qualifies for this particular therapy? What we are seeing in the first case is a person who has a disease, and on that basis, it might be legitimate that this kind of genetic intervention is appropriate for this individual. So, there might be some consensus that he should be a proper candidate to receive this genetic treatment.
In the case of the second lad who is only short because his parents are short, the case is a little more controversial but nonetheless, he insists that he too should be given this treatment because a disease is understood in terms of functionality. A disease is understood in terms of depressing functionality. He is not able to function as he needs to function in this society of much taller people. He might not have a disease but he unable to function in a proper way. So, whether it is a disease or whether it is a problem of functionality, he would argue that he is also an appropriate candidate. He makes a plea that in society he cannot find proper employment. He cannot do things for himself because he is so short. It certainly affects his social life and psychologically, it gives him great feelings of inferiority going around as a dwarf in a society of giants. So, he feels that he also be treated in this genetic treatment.
Now, so far as the third boy is concerned, the boy aspires to be a basketball star, and wants to be at least as tall as his six-foot six father, if not taller. He is rejected on the grounds that all of this is really treatment for people with disease in order to build them up to a certain level of normalcy., but this lad is already taller than a normal person and therefore the argument is made that he cannot be admitted to the same type of treatment. But the boy with his parents makes the argument that, “You are judging my case on the criterion of normalcy.”
Now what is normalcy? Normalcy is something which is arbitrarily fixed. Normalcy is on a trajectory which is defined by time and place. What might have seemed abnormal a few years ago, today what is abnormal becomes normal. People get used to it whether it is orthodontic work with children.
When my children were young, to put braces on them, it was really getting into something very elevated. Now all kids wear braces and no one thinks about it. So, what was innovative and not normal yesterday becomes normal in the course of time. So, it depends upon time and place. Normal is an arbitrary type of description to anything like that. So, he too is now making the case that even though he is not sick, even though he is above the normal, nonetheless, he requires this genetic treatment to help him to go to this added height.
So, if you try to make ethical decisions on the criterion of disease, on the criterion of functionality, even if the person doesn’t have a degree, but how well can a person function in society, functionality, or the criterion of normalcy? These can be debated, and you almost arbitrarily have to decide upon who is admitted and who is not admitted into this particular program.
So, instead of basing our response on these regular criteria, the bottom line of the Hindu response is that we have to think in terms of risks and benefits. Risks and benefits. This is a modern phrase—risk and benefits—and it is common phrase in the area of bioethics. But, in the Hindu tradition, it is based upon the fundamental concept of ahimsa. And the Sanskrit mandate is hiṁsā makuru vimoham, which is the same as the hypocritic oath of “do no harm,” something to which all medical doctors subscribe. So, this is just the bottom line.
Now the question is what is the Hindu response to genetic enhancement? So, we are going from therapy, which is the treatment of the disease, as in the case of boy number one, who is going to grow up as a dwarf, dwarfism, to enhancement for boy number three, where he has no illness; it is not a question of health, but it is a case of improvement. So, this is the dilemma that we are facing.
Now, Hindu bioethics distinguishes between number one, somatic cell gene therapy, and number two, enhancement genetic engineering. Now in terms of somatic cell gene therapy, there are many diseases such as ADA deficiency, sickle cell anemia, hemophilia, [?] disease. These are all the result of the defect of a single gene. Now in all such cases the patients are desperately ill. They are facing the attack of this monstrous disease. Everything must be done to alleviate their suffering. To be sure, there are great risks but in cutting edge technology, you always have to face risks, but the question is whether the benefits outweigh the risks. So, when we think in terms of the severe pain that they are suffering, the privations, the certain death, these are risks and uncertainties which are at acceptable levels.
Now the Hindu value on which we base our response to the diseases that I have mentioned, the Hindu value on which we proceed, is the value of dayā, which is translated in English as “compassion,” and that is correct, but it does not get to the real texture of dayā in Hindi thought. So, when we say compassion, when we say sympathy, when we quote such Judai-Christian verses as “I am my brother’s keeper,” Hinduism goes further than that. It is not just a case of, am I my brother’s keeper. But at least in the [tantric?] sense it is I am my brother, not I am my brother’s keeper, separation between myself and my brother whom I happen to keep, but I am my brother. There is that understanding of unity.
Another place in which this might come out in the western sense is “Do unto others as you would have them do unto you.” The dayā goes a little deeper. Do unto others as you would have them do unto you, there is a subject object difference between you and others and the reasoning is somewhat utilitarian: I do it for you and you do it for me. Almost like I scratch your back, you scratch my back.
This is the ethic is reciprocity, the ethic of mutuality. Dayā has nothing to do with reciprocity, dayā has nothing to do with mutuality; dayā has everything to do with identity, and that becomes the basis of greater motivation than this kind of arrangement which I help you, you help me, which is good, but this goes a little deeper.
Now, somatic cell gene therapy, while it is good, and which we endorse, also has a potential for enhancement genetic engineering. So, we have a slide from therapy to enhancement engineering, and by that I mean supplying specific characteristics that individuals want for themselves. This is somatic cell engineering which I want for myself. I want to grow taller, I want blonde hair, blue eyes—all of these things which in my society give me job opportunities, help make beautiful [images?]. These are the beautiful people. So, we have certain cultural concepts of beautiful people. “I want to be one of those beautiful people.” So that would be somatic engineering.
And the second is germline engineering. Germline engineering means continuing this to the next generation. But the problem over here is an ethical one because the moment you get into germline, then you are making decisions on the part of the children. They don’t have the voice. Furthermore, in germline engineering compared with other types of therapies, the other therapies you might be able to undo what you have done, but once it is introduced to the germline, you cannot undo it; it becomes relatively more permanent.
So, you have a slide from correction to perfection and the slide is already there. As I said, in the case of the human growth hormone, it was devised for children who faced the prospects of growing up as dwarfs, but then the slide began, and it was being used by children who only thought they were dwarfs. They thought that they were too short for their age. So, it is a matter of perception. Now these children perceived this and if they had wealthy parents to put up fifty thousand dollars to be able to have this type of therapy, then it is good for them.
Now Hindu bioethics believes that there is indeed a medical and a moral divide between somatic cell gene therapy and enhancement genetic engineering and that this line must not be crossed.
I will try to make the arguments for why the Hindu point of view would not want us to cross this line between correction and perfection, between therapy and enhancement. And I will base my arguments on two levels—one is the moral level and the second is the medical level.
So, we first look at this, keeping the line on the basis of morality, that is the first line of argument. First a fact must be reckoned with that self-improvement is as much of an American religion as being Baptist. Hindu bioethics has no problem with Baptists or with self-improvement. Hindu ethics will only ask that we be sure of the nature of the self, which is to be improved, what is the nature of the self that is to be improved.
Now arguing from one view of the self, a person could legitimately say there is absolutely no difference between getting one’s child a perfect education and I am sure many of you are paying big bucks for your children’s education in private schools. What is the difference between sending your children to a very expensive academy and getting one’s child a perfect gene? What is the difference? Hinduism would say there is a difference, and the difference is between cultivating capacities and purchasing capacities. Cultivating capacities and purchasing capacities. Buying a Harvard education could very well enhance a child’s natural gifts, but it is different to buying capacities for a child.
The Bhagavad-gītā said this a long time ago: let a man lift himself by himself. Let him not degrade himself for the self alone is the friend of the self and the self is the enemy of the self. Now the meaning of the Gītā is that personal transformation is always a function of the inner life. Personal transformation according to the Gītā is always a function of the inner life. Seeing with the third eye is not an acquisition of reconstructive laser surgery. To uplift oneself one must not rely on appendages which can be purchased at a price. To give the answer of the Gītā in one sentence, it would be this: self-improvement is improvement of the self. Self-improvement is improvement of the self.
Now we know from the moral arguments—there are many moral other arguments, but we will suffice with this—we go to the medical grounds. Hindu ethics perceives on the principle of ahimsa. This is part of the Indian tradition. It is strong in Hinduism, perhaps it is stronger in Buddhism, and it is strongest in Jainism, but all of the traditions emphasize ahimsa. So, this our basis.
Now somatic cell enhancement engineering threatens human values because of our limited knowledge which makes enhancement risky business at this juncture, at this stage of the research. We don’t know about the future at this stage of the research. There are the pioneers in the field. One of the best-known pioneers in the geneticist field is French Anderson and he cautions that though we have rough ideas of how simple genes work, and there are of course thousands of housekeeping genes that do the job of running cells, yet our understanding is limited when it comes to knowledge of how an organ develops, how it takes shape, how it takes form. This we do not know. Similarly, we know how the nervous system works in terms of electric circuits, in terms of memory storage, in terms of the transmission of signals, but yet we are far removed from understanding thought.
What is thought? Consciousness, Krishna consciousness. What is consciousness? What is Krishna consciousness? We don’t know these things from a medical point of view. Today we have few clues on how a thinking, loving, interacting organism can be derived from its molecules, but the day is coming when we can change some of those very molecules. Now this prospect of changing our very molecular structure, this has a person like Anderson quite worried and he says, and I quote, “There are probably genes that influence the brain’s organization structure, metabolism, and circuitry, making possible a human’s capacity to think abstractly, morally, and existentially, but what if in our innocent attempts to improve our genetic make-up, we alter one or more of those genes? Could we test for the alteration? Certainly not at present. If we caused a problem that would affect the individual or his or her offspring, could we repair the damage? Certainly not at present. Every parent who has several children knows that some babies accept and give more affection than others in the same environment. These genes control this. You have one child that loves to be cuddled, another child who does not want to be cuddled. These genes affect this. What if these genes were accidentally altered? Then that child who liked to be cuddled, maybe he will not want to be cuddled. Who knows?” Respectfully looking at this point, how would we even know if there has been an alteration in the first place? This is difficult.
I will tell you a story of when I was a little boy in Jhansi, my mother used to import from London beautiful ceramic clocks—very expensive. Now, I at that particular stage was exhibiting great curiosity. I really felt that I was an engineering genius waiting to be recognized and I would display my engineering curiosity by getting into my mother’s clock. Usually when she was doing something else, it was safe to do it. I felt I needed to get into this clock because as a child of about five or six I would hear a noise in the clock. Yes, there was a noise: tick tock, tick tock. There was a man inside, knocking on the door, wanting to get out. And I felt that it was my mission at age five to release this man. It is about jīvan-mukti. While this man is trapped for his karma or whatever reason, he is in the clock. I wanted to release this man. Instant mokṣa.
So, I would succeed in emptying the clock, but I always had a little difficulty in replacing all the parts in the way in which I originally found them. And my mother, she did not know child psychology, she could not recognize infantile genius, and she would react to my experiments rather inappropriately.
Another Hindu concept which comes into this consideration is consequentialism. Consequentialism understood in terms of karma that everything that is done, there is some kind of reaction—cause and effect. Now, the point is that we don’t even know the cause very well and we have very little notion of effects.
In Frankenstein movies there is always the announcement to the jittery audience, “These experiments will not go as originally planned.” and that is the situation. We don’t know how these experiments will go. Who can predict all the side effects? Can we be certain that a child engineered to become intellectually sharp could actually turn out modelling me. A child that we want to be modelled after Gandhi and he turns into a bodmash. Translate that. So, we can’t predict that kind of thing. This is also another reason why we have to be cautious.
Then Hindu bioethics appeals to the principle of justice based on a common spiritual heritage and the connectivity of all existence. In Hinduism all life comes from one source called parameśvara. The Bhagavad-gītā says, “When one sees Me everywhere and everything in Me, I am never lost to him, and he is never lost to Me.” Now this talk of the Gītā invests the individual with equality, and it rings with the question of social fairness. Do we wish to usher in a society where the rich who can afford it become smarter? Who will have the right to access the technology once it becomes financially out of reach for the common person? Every parent would want his or her child to become intellectually enhanced but only a minority will be able to afford it. Would this not create a new caste system in which the wealthy brahmans of society constitute a new intellectual aristocracy that looks down upon the sudras of society, the people who don’t have the same kind of IQs that they possess?
Fifth, is enhancing our abilities medically sound? And the answer of the Indian medical system of Ayurveda is clear. In Ayurveda, health is understood in terms of balance, and this balance is always precarious because of internal factors and external factors. I can’t go into it, but balance is always precarious, and we have to keep the doshas in equilibrium with one another, to help us to a state of equilibrium.
There is a neuro biologist, Alcino Silva from UCLA who says on this point, he says every [cutting?] comes at a price. Very often when there is a genetic change, where we improve something, something else gets hit by it. So it is never a clean thing. So, when it comes to balance, we don’t know what can be thrown out of balance when we begin manipulation of the genes in this way.
Sixthly, the pluralistic approach of Hindu ethics values diversity and it finds richness in individuality that is devised by the evolutionary wisdom of mother nature. Mother nature does not put all of her eggs in one basket. Therefore, the prospects of a homogenized society, a society that is shaped by certain dominant traits and values that everyone is wanting, “I want to be like [Mike?],” a few years ago. I want to be like Mike. All the kids wanted to be like this super star. So all of us are wanting the same kind of things, a very homogenized society, and this is very frightening.
Seventh, Hindu bioethics adopts an inclusive approach towards humans and all forms of beings. In the west, Christian-Jewish ideas, when they talk about do no harm, they are talking about do no harm to whom? To human beings. Thus only to human beings. But within the Hindu concept, we think of do no harm not only to human beings but always to all sentient creatures. All sentient creatures. For example, genetically engineered super pigs and kittens may increase the amount of food for human consumption but what about the effects upon the animals themselves? That does not quite enter the consciousness. You have to have Krishna consciousness to bring animals into it.
So let me conclude by saying that in Hindu bioethics the cause of our emanationist view as we find in the Gītā of a God expressing Himself through various life forms and this is always on the move. Dharma itself is a very dynamic concept. There is nothing static about dharma even though many Hindus tend to make it very static and freeze it in history that dharma has to be released from history. It is always trying to understand the modern situation and to relate to it.
So, with that type of a background, Hinduism would not take a position towards genetic enhancement that you find say in the Roman Catholic church which says that genetic enhancement is intrinsically bad. That is, it is in and of itself bad—intrinsically. But Hindu bioethics would say we have to exercise caution now, but we look down the road at science where we are revising itself, experimenting, and who knows, things might change. Transformation might come about. But Hindu bioethics is always clear in its definition of transformation. Transformation must be through us. To recognize us as persons, transformation must be through us, not to us. Transformation which is to us reduces the person who [is covered?], something manufactured, something cooked up in the laboratory.
I conclude with the words of Gandhi who said, “As human beings our greatness lies not so much in being able to remake the world as in being able to remake ourselves.” Daṇḍavat. [applause]
Krishna Kripa dasa: Thank you, Professor Crawford. Please give a round of applause. Next is Giriraj Maharaja. He needs little introduction but when I say little, as far as his spirituality is concerned, it is a lot. So I will briefly tell you what Maharaja brings to the podium. He is going to talk on the same subject as far as Vaishnava perspective is concerned.
Maharaja was initiated by Srila Prabhupada many years ago which by the way tomorrow we have a very special program for Srila Prabhupada’s disappearance day. Maharaja himself is also an initiating spiritual master. He is a GBC (Governing Body Commissioner) and an author of many articles and projects. And he has also written many books. Maharaja is currently responsible for South Africa, India, and Mauritius, and he is the pioneer of the Bombay Juhu temple project. As Professor Crawford mentioned during his opening remarks that the temple in Bombay cancelled his room reservation and treated him like one of their own brothers. So Maharaja is a pioneer of our Bombay Juhu temple project.
Maharaja is also a well liked and gracious consultant to many of our ISKCON leaders, members, about the Hare Krishna philosophy, the practice of Krishna consciousness and [initiated?] projects. Why Maharaja is a gracious consultant for all these wonderful things that goes on in the ISKCON movement? Because Maharaja received his training from no one other than Srila Prabhupada.
So without any further ado, I would like to request His Holiness Giriraj Maharaja to speak on the subject.
Giriraj Swami:
First, I must thank Dr. Crawford for his wonderful presentation. It was very clear and powerful and humorous when appropriate.
I will not attempt to repeat what Dr. Crawford said or to analyze it in detail. Rather, I would present another aspect of Vaishnava thought based on the Bhagavad-gītā and Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam which emphasizes the spiritual aspect of life and the spiritual purpose of life.
According to Sri Chaitanya Mahaprabhu who is considered to be the incarnation of Krishna for the present age and who even otherwise is considered the foremost authority and exponent of Vedic literatures in the last several hundred years, has informed us that the Vedic scriptures deal with three subjects, three divisions of knowledge. One is called sambandha-jnana. Sambandha-jnana means knowledge of one’s own self, knowledge of the Supreme Self, and knowledge of the relationship between the individual self and the Supreme Self. And Sri Chaitanya Mahaprabhu has summarized in one line: jīvera ‘svarūpa’ haya—kṛṣṇera ‘nitya-dāsa’, that the constitutional position of the living entity is to be the eternal servant of Krishna or God.
The next division of knowledge is called abhidheya. Abhidheya describes our activities in relation to the Supreme Soul or the appropriate activities for the living entity. And that is in essence bhakti-yoga.
And the third division of knowledge is prayojana. Prayojana means the “goal of life.” According to Sri Chaitanya Mahaprabhu and of course whatever He said could be documented with references from Vedic literatures, prema pumārtho mahān: the goal of life is to develop pure love of Godhead.
Now, from the very beginning of Bhagavad-gītā, we learn that the soul, ātmā or jīvātmā, is distinct from the body: dehino ‘smin yathā dehe kaumāraṁ yauvanaṁ jarā tathā dehāntara-prāptir dhīras tatra na muhyati, that just as one passes from childhood to youth to old age, similarly at the time of death, one enters into another body.
When I was born, I had a completely different body than I have now. If I showed you pictures of ten babies, you wouldn’t know which one is Giriraj Swami because that body and this body are different. Similarly, when I am an older man, say any old man, he may struggle to walk with a cane, but he can remember that, “I used to be a young man and I used to run and jump and play.” So the body he has as an old man is not the same body he had as a youth. But he is the same person. He remembers what he used to do when he had the youth’s body or the child’s body. And even in ordinary affairs people say, “Oh, you have grown so much. I remember when you were like this; now you are like this.” So people recognize him as the same person, but the body has changed. Therefore, the actual person is not the body, but he is the soul within the body.
And the Bhagavad-gītā says that the body is like a dress. Just like I am wearing this dress today, tomorrow I’ll wear another dress. Just as one wears some clothing, but when the particular clothing becomes old and useless, it is discarded and one puts on some new clothing, similarly the soul wears this body like clothing, and when the body becomes old and useless, we leave this body and we get another body, and that is the transmigration of the soul.
Now the Bhagavad-gītā further informs us that in every body, in every species of life, from the highest planet of Brahmaloka to the lowest planet, there is the repetition of birth and death. Ābrahma-bhuvanāl lokāḥ punar āvartino. And in every species of life, there are four miseries that we cannot escape, janma-mṛtyu-jarā-vyādhi-duḥkha-doṣānudarśanam: birth, disease, old age, and death. We may be a deva or devi on a higher planet, we still suffer birth, disease, old age, and death. And this has been true at all times—in the past, it is true in the present, and it will be true at all times in the future.
So yes, we care for our clothing, but we don’t identify with the clothing. We don’t think, “I am this shirt, I am this coat.” Because people identify with the body, they fight. They identify, “I am Hindu, you are Muslim.” Or “I am American, you are Chinese,” or whatever—man, woman, black, white. But if we think that, “I am wearing a red dress, he is wearing white clothes, so we fight,” it doesn’t make sense. So, on the negative side, we face so many problems because we identify with the body, and we miss the actual purpose of life which, as Dr. Crawford so aptly said, is the elevation of the self.
Now it is true that we are seeking perfection and it is also true that perfection is possible but not in relation to the body. Perfection is possible in relation to the soul when the soul realizes it is eternal relationship with the Supreme Soul. Yes, we want a perfect child, but we cannot manufacture a perfect child in the material world. But if we become pure in our love for Krishna, we can have Krishna as our child. He will be the perfect child. Yes, we want a perfect husband, and if we become perfect in our spiritual development and develop pure love for Krishna, Krishna will become our perfect husband. We want a perfect friend, Krishna is ready, He’ll become our perfect friend.
So, perfection is possible but not in the material realm. The material realm is not meant for perfection, but perfection is possible in the spiritual realm. And therefore the Bhagavad-gītā and Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam advise us to focus our efforts and energies on self-realization which automatically results in mukti or liberation from the cycle of birth and death and repetition of birth and death and disease and old age.
So what about material progress? Yes, this issue of genetic engineering is very delicate and complex, but in a broader sense it is just one aspect of material progress, the effort to achieve material progress. And what do the Bhagavad-gītā and Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam say about that? The Bhāgavatam says that just as unhappiness comes of its own accord—nobody wants unhappiness, no one goes to the temple and prays to God, “God, please give me more dukha, please give me more suffering.” Everybody wants sukha, everyone wants happiness—so the Bhāgavatam says that just as unhappiness comes without your making any effort, similarly, happiness will also come without you making any effort. You are destined to achieve a certain amount of happiness and unhappiness. And you cannot change that by material means. But, by revival of divine consciousness, Krishna consciousness, you can experience transcendental happiness that is beyond the duality of the material world and beyond the body. So that is the goal.
Now, as far as material progress, the Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam says that although materialistic people adopt so many means to better their material positions, often the cures that they adopt are worse than the diseases. And that is exactly part of what Dr. Crawford mentioned in a very scientific and eloquent way that we are trying to counteract the miseries of material existence by material means, but our efforts to do so without reference to God will not succeed. And therefore often the solution we create to solve one problem creates two or ten or twenty new problems.
So, the Bhāgavatam says, and it is not that we are against material progress, but the Bhāgavatam says that rather than focus on trying to increase our material happiness and decrease our material distress, which will come in any case, we should rather use our energy for spiritual realization. And that is the main defect in the modern civilization that people give too much emphasis to the body, to the clothing. They are trying to make a stronger cloth with permanent indelible dye that will never rip. But what about you, what about the person who is wearing the cloth? You are not even thinking about that person. You are not even talking about that person. So that is the main defect.
Now, how do we realize our self, how do we realize our eternal relationship with God? Well that is bhakti-yoga and of course there are other types of yoga that also elevate one in self-realization and God realization—karma-yoga, jnana-yoga, ashtanga-yoga—but they are meant ultimately to culminate in bhakti-yoga. And that is stated clearly in Bhagavad-gītā: bhaktyā mām abhijānāti, that only by bhakti can Krishna be known. That is our goal to know Krishna and love Him. But within bhakti-yoga, again there are different processes—śravaṇaṁ kīrtanaṁ viṣṇoḥ smaraṇaṁ pāda-sevanam arcanaṁ vandanaṁ dāsyaṁ sakhyam ātma-nivedanam —there are nine broad [categories]. Those have also been analyzed into sixty-four, but out of those sixty-four, nine are most prominent. Out of those nine, three are most important: śravaṇaṁ kīrtanaṁ viṣṇoḥ smaraṇaṁ: hearing and chanting and remembering Vishnu, God. And out of those, one is most important, and that is chanting the holy names. And therefore the scriptures recommend and Sri Chaitanya Mahaprabhu has recommended and our line of teachers from Krishna and Chaitanya Mahaprabhu have also recommended:
harer nāma harer nāma
harer nāmaiva kevalam
kalau nāsty eva nāsty eva
nāsty eva gatir anyathā
“One should chant the holy names, chant the holy names, chant the holy names. There is no other way, no other way, no other way for success in the present age.”
Now I am not talking about a sectarian idea, not at all. Yes, we chant the Hare Krishna maha-mantra, that is mentioned in the Vedic literatures and given to us by Sri Chaitanya Mahaprabhu, but any name of God in any scripture of the world can be chanted. God has many names in different scriptures in different languages, and any name of God, any name that refers to same Supreme Being, can be chanted to the same effect. And the result will be that one will become nonviolent. I very much welcomed the learned professor’s statement about nonviolence (ahimsa). And although people appreciate the ideal of nonviolence, often they cannot live up to it because of unwanted things within the heart—lust, anger, greed, and so on. So the effect of chanting is ceto-darpaṇa-mārjanam: it cleanses the dirt from within the heart. So we naturally become nonviolent.
But there is also a problem there that one cannot be completely nonviolent in the material world no matter how much one tries. It is the highest ideal in Buddhism and in Jainism. There are orthodox Jains—I have even seen them in Bombay where I lived for almost thirty years—they wear masks on their faces so that by breathing the air they don’t kill germs. They walk with a broom, and they sweep the road in front of them so that they will not step on any insects. They will not light a fire after sunset to cook because they do not want any insects or creatures to fly into the fire and be killed. And of course they are strictly vegetarian. They won’t eat onions or potatoes or other vegetables of the earth. Most vegetables can be eaten without taking the life of the plant. You take the fruit from the vine, the vegetable from the stalk, but with an onion, when you take the onion out, you kill the plant. So they don’t even take onions or potatoes.
So that is a very worthy ideal—ahimsa—not to kill any creature because we have no right to kill any creature because we can’t create life; life is created by God, and it is a violation of God’s arrangement to kill. Now, of course there is no such thing as killing for the soul, so what we are actually talking about is that it is God’s arrangement that a particular soul will live in a particular body for a certain duration of time. So, to kill someone means to forcibly make the soul vacate that body before the time that God has allotted for the soul to live in that body. And why is that sinful apart from its transgression of God’s law? It is sinful because every soul is meant to progress through the different species of life to come to the human form of life and in the human form of life to realize oneself and God. So, when we interrupt the duration of life of a living entity within a particular body, we are denying it the chance to progress to the next species in natural course. It will have to come back again because it has to spend a certain amount of time in a particular species before it can progress.
So, with all those efforts—the masks and sweeping and all those—it is not possible; you cannot live in this world without killing. And once you kill, you are involved in sinful activity. You have to suffer the reaction.
So what is the solution? So, here again we come back to bhakti-yoga, to devotional service, that if we kill just out of carelessness or even inadvertently, but if we do so on our own account, we are guilty of killing, and we have to suffer the reaction, but if we do everything for the sake of God, in the service of God, then we are not doing it on our account, then we are not responsible. Just like if we run a red light, we are guilty of a violation, we can get a ticket, but if a policeman runs through the red light, he doesn’t get a ticket, because he is authorized to run through the red light, because he is not doing it for himself; he is doing it for his work, he is doing it for the state.
Even apart from killing, even if we pluck an apple from a tree, or a tomato from a vine, we are causing pain. Those plants feel pain. We are not killing but we are causing them pain; that is also sinful. We also have to suffer the reaction. So what is the solution. Are we completely bound to commit sin everywhere we turn no matter what we do? The solution is to do everything for God.
So yes, if you take an apple from the tree, we are causing pain to the tree, and if we eat it, we are still liable for the pain we cause to the tree. But if we offer that apple to God, to Krishna, then the soul that is in the body of the tree gets the credit of offering its fruit to the Lord. And that fortunate soul, instead of having to transmigrate through so many different gradations of species of life, can immediately be promoted to the human form of life, because it did devotional service. It offered its fruit to Krishna.
So therefore Krishna consciousness or devotional service [break in recording].
So I am very heartened by Dr. Crawford’s presentation. He has really gone deeply into the subject and in one sense he maybe more knowledgeable in some types of Vedic literature than we are, and he can tell us what different types of our Vedic literature say about different aspects of life, because there are so many Vedic literatures. But the essence of the Vedas is the Bhagavad-gītā and the Bhagavad-gītā begins from the point that we are not the body, that we are the soul within the body.
And from there onwards I think that we can work together with Dr. Crawford to remind people of their actual identities as the soul; not the body, not the mind, not the intelligence, not the false ego, but as the soul, and remind them of their real mission in human life which is to realize themselves as souls and to achieve perfection as souls. There is actually a technical word, svarūpa-siddhi, that is the perfection of realizing one’s eternal spiritual identity. And when one realizes svarūpa-siddhi by bhakti-yoga, one realizes one’s eternal spiritual identity which is perfect. There is no birth, death, disease, or old age. Whatever they do with their engineering, I don’t think they are going to be able to remove disease, old age, and death or rebirth. But when you achieve svarūpa-siddhi, no more disease, no old age, no death, and no rebirth, and that perfect friend, that perfect child, that perfect spouse that you wanted will be yours in the form of the Lord Himself whom we call Krishna.
Thank you very much. [applause]
Krishna Kripa dasa: We have some time for a couple of questions. While you are thinking of your questions, once again I’d like to thank Dr. Crawford and His Holiness Giriraj Maharaja for enlightening us on this very special and very unique topic, and we got to hear the devotee’s perspective, the science, and also the philosophy and spirituality of the bioethics issue. Thank you very much once again.
Anyone have any questions for Maharaja or Dr. Crawford?
Question: I was wondering about euthanasia and taking lives before being ready for that life to be taken. I am wondering is there a way to relieve somebody’s suffering without violating God’s laws?
Giriraj Swami: As I mentioned earlier, there is really no death for the soul. What we call death is really the soul leaving one body and going into another or leaving an old set of clothes and getting a new set of clothes. So the real question is not really to avoid death in an unnatural way or to [cause?] death in an unnatural way. But the real issue is to prepare for death. Now the Bhagavad-gītā says, yaṁ yaṁ vāpi smaran bhāvam that whatever you think of at the time of death will determine your next life, and it also says that if you think of Him at the time of death, you’ll go to Him, and that is the goal. So the best service that we can render at this time is to help them think of God at the time of death.
I have seen the same principle in other traditions. Although I was based in Bombay, part of my area of responsibility was in Pakistan and Sri Lanka, and in Pakistan I came across a book called The Ninety-nine Names of Allah, just like in the Vedic tradition there are the thousand names of Vishnu, the Viṣṇu-sahasra-nāma. and then The Ninety-nine Names of Allah. And the goal, according to that book, is for the person to chant one of the names of Allah at the time of death. And the duty of the family members and friends is to help the person to remember the name of Allah at the time of death. I also know in the Jewish tradition that is also the goal, at the time of death they will chant the name of God in that tradition.
So that would be our best service to them. But if a person feels that, “Okay, I have lived enough in this body,” and he doesn’t want to take measures to prolong his life in the body when his duration of life in the body is coming to a natural end, he is free to leave. There are devotees who choose, they often choose not to go into a hospital, not to be put on life support, because they want their consciousness to be free to remember God; they don’t want to be surrounded by nurses and doctors and needles and tubes. And they have that right, they have that right.
But we do not accept the idea that someone kills himself or to find unnatural means to leave this body. Even if he or she is in pain, we have to take it that when we are ready or when God is ready, He’ll take us. But we are not against administering medication to reduce the pain. We are not against medical treatment or pain control. But I know many devotees, they always have a balance, because they want their consciousness to be clear at the time of death, because they want to be able to chant the name of God at the time of death. So, they will accept some degree of pain medication but not to the extent that it will dull their consciousness and hinder their remembrance of God at the time of death.
Professor Crawford: Yes, that would be precisely my point of view too. If you want the literature to look at it, you could look at the dharma-shastras, and there it is quite spelled out and historically too, in the Indian tradition, suicide is only the privilege of the holy person. This looks like a contradiction for many people, but it is the person who is self-realized. Now a person who is self-realized by definition has died to the body so that death is only the final physical act of something which has already taken place in a spiritual way.
But, while this person is in the state of illness which is terminating his life, he knows that today he might be able to bear the pain but tomorrow this might not be possible. And this will put him in a certain frame of mind or spirit which would be against that moment which the swami talked about to be at peace. This is what euthanasia itself means, to be in a certain state of peace. He would be deprived of that. He does not want to be deprived of that and therefore he lets himself go by usually through starvation of not taking water of not taking food. And in the dharma-shastras he is allowed to go on great journeys. He wanders around without partaking of any food or of any drink. The Jains have developed that to a great perfection—sarva kaṇa.
Question: I just wanted to know about the ethical consideration with things like stem cell research dealing with an embryo, [which will last for?] three days old and will either be discarded or used for research for genetic purposes.
Professor Crawford: I already told Dr. Medley this was not the subject of our discussion. You came in late. We took another thing. Stem cell research is a big subject, and I will be glad to return to the temple some time and talk about it, but I really don’t want to get into that. It is a subject unto itself. We are talking about genetic enhancement in this talk.
Dive into the Nectar
Books by Giriraj Swami

Dancing White Elephants
Traveling with Srila Prabhupada in India, August 1970-March 1972

I'll Build You a Temple
The epic story of challenge and triumph in the founding of the Juhu temple.

Watering the Seed
Anecdotes from the pastimes and teachings of Srila Prabhupada.

Many Moons
A recollection and celebration of the wonderful qualities, and activities of devotees who have left our vision

Life's Final Exam
Death and Dying from the Vedic Perspective
Deepen Your Spiritual Journey
Weekly Inspiration from Giriraj Swami
Sign up to receive weekly emails with exclusive content from Giriraj Swami, including recent lectures, excerpts from upcoming books, and announcements about workshops and retreats. Dive deeper into Krishna consciousness and stay connected with a community of like-minded seekers on your spiritual path.

