Japa Retreat Level 3—Chanting with Longing
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Giriraj Swami: Hare Krishna.
You have prepared me very well to speak because I am longing to hear more from you.
Sacinandana Swami: If you wish, I can tell you this meditation on which Bhaktivinoda Thakura said. It is very congenial with your own worship of Srila Prabhupada. I think you worship your Prabhupada regularly.
Giriraj Swami: It is Prabhupada and Haridasa Thakura.
It was a very profound talk you gave—philosophical and emotional—very penetrating. When you ended it wasn’t the true ended, but the apparent ending at 8:08. I was actually thinking of beginning my talk with that line in the Bhagavad-gītā: saṅgāt sañjāyate kāmaḥ.
As you were saying, Srila Prabhupada often gave different answers to the same question, but the answers were only apparently different. If you investigated more deeply, you would find that the answers were the same. Once I heard Srila Prabhupada said that Krishna consciousness is 90 percent association and so saṅgāt sañjāyate kāmaḥ, our desire develops from saṅga, from association.
Association can be of two types—vāṇī and vapuḥ. Vāṇī of course means “transcendental sound or words” and vapuḥ means “physical presence.” By association we become attached. That is all part of that sequence in the Bhagavad-gītā that when the senses dwell on the objects of the senses, lust develops or attachment. We cannot really feel separation from anyone or anything unless we have some attachment for the person or thing. To develop that attachment, we have to have association. Generally, in the spiritual field, we become attached first to our spiritual master, to Srila Prabhupada, then to Lord Nityananda and Lord Chaitanya, and then to Krishna, Radha and Krishna. One of the reasons is that we know our spiritual master, we have seen him, we have heard from him, we have spoken to him, we have rendered personal service to him. By that association we have become attached to him and therefore when we are deprived of that association, we feel separation from him. That can apply to other devotees who are śikṣā-gurus to us.
But when we go further down the line, we don’t have that direct personal touch as we have with the spiritual master or other Vaishnavas who we can see and speak to, touch, smell, and so on. So we associate with them by vāṇī, by hearing about them, and by hearing about them, we can become attached to them.
One of the striking examples to me from Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam is the case of princess Rukmini who simply by hearing about Krishna became so attached to Him that she wanted to have Him as her husband and no one else. We too when we hear about Krishna or Chaitanya Mahaprabhu, we can develop that desire to meet the person and associate with the person and join the person in his pastimes and serve the person in his pastimes. Srila Prabhupada introduced the practice in ISKCON of reading the Kṛṣṇa book every night before taking rest—we discussed this at the retreat in New Vrindavan—because we chant the holy name but if we chant nicely and our consciousness is properly prepared, chanting the name will naturally remind us of the Lord’s form and qualities and pastimes. Srila Prabhupada had said that if you read the Kṛṣṇa book then whatever you see will remind you of Krishna. So, we applied the same idea or principle that every night we should read the Kṛṣṇa book or some transcendental literature involving the pastimes of the Lord or the Lord’s devotees and then when we go to sleep, absorbed in the Lord’s pastimes, it will be somewhat natural the next morning when we chant that we will remember the Lord’s pastimes with that hankering or yearning to become part of His entourage in His pastimes.
So we need to associate and the association of the Lord through the holy name, form, qualities, and pastimes of the Lord is enhanced by doing that in the association of other devotees who have that desire or eagerness or anxiety, and we experience it when we chant and hear with them.
When I entered the room here the day before yesterday on the sixty-round round day, I came close to the altar to see the Deities, and I was transfixed. I just sat down on the floor. I didn’t want to leave and I was feeling waves of mercy and love coming from Haridasa Thakura for the devotees. Of course, Radha-Kanaiyalala. Radharani looked like She was dancing. Her skirt and braid were flying in the air. The chanting flowed very easily and I thought, “Wow! This is Prabhupada’s mercy.” I was not doing it. This was Prabhupada’s mercy. But more than Prabhupada’s mercy or along with Prabhupada’s mercy, I also knew that it was the association of the devotees around me that was uplifting me. Arcana Siddhi Mataji was there. Then you came. Eventually Yajna-purusa Prabhu came. And I thought it is because of the association and chanting of all of these devotees that I am being carried along like this. If we can associate with Krishna through the holy name, form, qualities, pastimes as in the Līlā-kīrtana in the association of devotees who have eagerness and taste, then that enhances our experience and desire—saṅgāt sañjāyate kāmaḥ.
The real challenge that we face when we leave the retreat is how to do it without the strong association. I remember after the very first retreat I attended which was an extremely powerful experience. . . actually in the initial stage after Puruṣa-sūkta Prabhu had the idea of beginning a spiritual care initiative, the question was how, in what way do we proceed, and he sent a letter to different devotees who had been at the first meeting or who had expressed interest, “What would you like to do, and with whom would you like to do it.” So I responded I would like to do it with Sacinandana Swami because you were on the list and I hadn’t had your association for some years. Based on our mutual desire, it was arranged that there would be a japa retreat with you in Ojai, California, just a few minutes from Santa Barbara. But then you became ill and you couldn’t travel and you were thinking, “We have to cancel the retreat.” But Puruṣa-sūkta Prabhu said, “No, we will not cancel. We will do it anyway.”
Somehow Ravindra Svarupa Prabhu came and I was there and it was very intimate retreat. It was all Prabhupada disciples. The devotees really opened up their hearts to each other. We all felt so close to each other through that experience as we are experiencing here. We were really close to each other, especially many of us had served together so many years before, decades before. We all had very profound experiences and we were all determined that we would apply what we had learned at the retreat in our daily lives. For a few days it was like that—there was so much momentum—but then, little by little, it got a little deflated, deflated, and deflated, and then one of the participants phoned and said, “I can’t do it on my own. We need each other. We are not that strong. I can’t do it on my own. We have to make some arrangement to get together.”
So that principle of association, that spiritual association through vāṇī is always available. We can always chant, we can always read, we can always look at a picture of Krishna or Deity and feel some longing, but again, as you were discussing the culture, if we are separated from devotees and then furthermore have to work in a job with non-devotees, the whole culture around us is surcharged with materialism. I have heard so many devotees say that the greatest hardship in their work is the association. It is not actually the work itself but it is the association and the low level of consciousness of the people, the low level of conversation. It is a terrible hardship. After a day of that you come home you have time, but you are just so drained of your enthusiasm for Krishna consciousness, it is really hard to pick yourself up.
And that is where association is so important. Even when we preach and have to deal a lot with the material world—different varieties of people—I find that I chant better in the association of other devotees because it helps to keep me focused. And it is not very often but if I go away somewhere on a personal retreat and I have no other association—it is just me and the holy name and my deities and I don’t really interact with anyone and even devotees—then I can just sit and chant, just me and the holy name and Srila Prabhupada and Haridasa Thakura and Lord Chaitanya. But otherwise I need that support of the association of devotees to keep that focus of intention.
Now Srila Prabhupada in the purport to The Nectar of Instruction has taken this verse—saṅgāt sañjāyate kāmaḥ—in a positive way or in a neutral way that by association one develops desire, but in the original context in which the verse appears in the Bhagavad-gītā, it is part of the cycle of degradation that when the senses dwell on the objects of the senses, lust develops. From lust, attachment, from. . . and the whole anger, forgetfulness, and then falls into the material whirlpool.
How subtle association is, is illustrated in a story I heard from a young lady who met Srila Prabhupada when he first came to Los Angeles. She was young Gujarati girl. This was in 1970. She had recently married an Indian man and she had come with him to America, to Los Angeles. In those days there weren’t so many Indians in America and the movement was very new. I imagine that Prabhupada’s cooks were not so. . . whatever it is, he engaged the young lady in cooking for him. She would regularly come and cook upstairs at Watseka Avenue. She was young, she had just come from India, I am sure she missed home. And Prabhupada was there with his disciples. But then she was there, like another Indian. So he developed a very paternal relationship with her and sometimes he would come from his room and look in the kitchen and chat with her. They had a very free and open relationship. She would just confide in him like to a grandfather.
So one day she said, “Prabhupada, I want to go to a department store.” In those in India there were no department stores. There were either vendors on the street or there would be a store for a specific item, but not a department store where you go in and there is everything under one roof. She said, “Prabhupada, I want to see a department store.” And Srila Prabhupada said, “No, don’t go.” She said, “No, I just want to see it. I have never seen it. I just want to go once.” And Prabhupada said, “No, don’t go.” And then she was very disappointed. She said, “Just to see once out of curiosity. What’s the problem?” And Srila Prabhupada replied, “When you go to the department store you will see so many things that you didn’t even know existed and when you see them you will develop a desire for them. As long as you have material desires you have to take birth in the material world.”
That is saṅgāt sañjāyate kāmaḥ. He didn’t want her senses to dwell on the objects of the senses in the department store because attachment would develop and that attachment would bind her to the material world.
Now we talk about the culture we are in. Shopping is for many people a major part of life. They even have this term “retail therapy.” If you feel depressed, if you feel down, just go out and shop. You feel better. Even our esteemed former president, George W. Bush, after the attack on the twin towers on 9/11 he addressed the people of America and he told them that, “Our enemies (the Al Qaida), they are against our system, they want to destroy us and they have struck fear in our hearts, and the best way that we can defeat them and show that they have not succeeded in destroying our way of life is to go out and shop.” [laughter] That was his message to the people of America [laughter]. So, it is such a culture we are in. It is terrible.
And then Srila Prabhupada said something that was very poignant because the young lady, she kept insisting. She was probably eighteen years old, really just young, newly married girl. She was pouting he wasn’t letting her go. And then Prabhupada said, “You are arguing with me now, but one day when I am not here, you will remember how you argued with me and you will regret it.” That was a very poignant statement and that actually invokes the mood of separation. When you feel separation, petty insignificant things pale and disappear. They just do not matter.
Prabhupada talks about śmaśāna-vairāgya, the renunciation of the crematorium; I have seen it in India. The richest Indian family at that time—newly rich family—the Hindujas, their son, only son of the eldest brother had died. It was quite a story. So they brought the body, he was actually in a fire in Mauritius. It was a very complicated story and they brought him to England for medical treatment and it failed and he died and then they brought the body to Bombay. And then eventually there was a cremation and the Hinduja family invited us to attend and do kirtan.
Afterwards there was another very wealthy Sindhi businessman who I knew quite well and he came up to me and he said, “You see this and you wonder what are we doing all this for, all this making money, building buildings, getting name and fame, what are we doing this all for.” That sense of renunciation comes, but in the case of ordinary people, it doesn’t last. śmaśāna-vairāgya. Okay, they feel like that for a day or two, but then business as usual.
But with devotees that feeling of separation automatically brings attachment. They go together. That famous verse, bhaktiḥ pareśānubhavo viraktir anyatra caiṣa, that. . . I relate that to a question that someone asked Srila Prabhupada that very much relates to the subject of longing while chanting. One disciple asked Srila Prabhupada on a morning walk, “How can we know if we are chanting with quality?” And Srila Prabhupada replied that, “When the quality is there you will know it. You won’t have to ask.” And then he quoted this verse that when you are hungry and you are eating, you don’t have to ask someone, “Am I satisfied? You don’t have to take a certificate, ‘Now you have eaten. Now you are satisfied.’ You feel satisfied.” And then he said that, “When the quality comes you will know it. You won’t have to ask if the quality has come.” And then he quoted that, “When the quality comes, govinda-viraheṇa me, you will feel that in the absence of Govinda the whole universe is vacant. So that is quality.” But he said that that is not so cheap. Like now we chant as a matter of duty. We have taken our vow to chant our prescribed number of rounds, sixteen rounds. Right now we chant as a matter of duty. We have to do it in the hope that one day that quality will come, but that quality is not an easy thing or such a cheap thing. And he mentioned āsakti which is the stage just before bhava that then you can chant with quality, with feeling—govinda-viraheṇa me.
And then he connected it to enthusiasm, because as we have been discussing desire, eagerness, anxiety, there is also enthusiasm. Prabhupada has also said that without enthusiasm you can’t do anything, you can’t make progress in anything. And he said, “Just like me, I get up in the middle of the night and write. No one is forcing me. No one is watching me. No one is telling me but naturally I am enthusiastic. I want to get up after two hours of rest. I want to write these books. I have that enthusiasm. No one can force that on you. No one can tell you but has to be there within you.” And he said, “Therefore people appreciate my books so much, people like my purports so much, because they come out of my natural enthusiasm.” Of course in another context Srila Prabhupada said that his purports were his personal ecstasies, but it is the same idea.
So he said maybe after so many lifetimes that quality will come, but for now we do our duty in the hope that that quality will come. But of course now we also have this association of devotees and making a systematic attempt to. . . like you said we can’t crank it up or jack it up, but by hearing and association that desire to be Krishna consciousness arises. Again I come back to association—saṅgāt sañjāyate kāmaḥ—because we have all the facilities at home. We have our chanting beads, we have our deities, we have our set of books, or our IPods. We can be filled with kṛṣṇa-kathā and kṛṣṇa-nāma day and night if we want, but because of the innovating mundane environment, we lose our enthusiasm, and to get that enthusiasm we need that association of devotees.
One other point, sometimes we think of association in terms of chanting and hearing together—as we are doing. Another type of association is through serving the person. In the First Canto, Second Chapter we have a series of verses that describe the gradual development of Krishna consciousness through the different stages and there is vāsudeva-kathā-ruciḥ syān mahat-sevayā viprāḥ, that by serving great souls, one develops ruci, one develops taste for the message of Krsna.
So again, after living in temples for thirty years from the day I joined, because of my health and circumstances, I had to change my lifestyle. So I am no longer living in temples most of the time. But fortunately I had a facility that could accommodate godbrothers to come and visit me and I found in the absence of living in a temple, having godbrothers stay with me was encouraging. But it wasn’t just that they were staying and we would take prasāda together and we would talk, but I saw it as an opportunity to serve them.
There is a nice and purport in Caitanya-caritāmṛta, Srila Prabhupada talks about how Lord Chaitanya gave the instruction every year to chant the holy name and serve the Vaishnavas and then the residents of Kulīna-grāma would ask, “How do we recognize a Vaishnava?” and Srila Prabhupada explains that in the first year Lord Chaitanya said that, “Anyone who chants the holy name once is a Vaishnava and you should serve him.” And Srila Prabhupada said that verse refers to the neophyte who is just beginning to chant. And then the next year when they asked, Lord Chaitanya says, “One who is always chanting the holy name is an advanced devotee and you should serve him.” Srila Prabhupada said that that refers to madhyam, but in this case Prabhupada uses the word “advanced.” In this sequence he refers to kaniṣṭhā, madhyam, and uttamā as neophyte, advanced, and perfect. You should serve the advanced devotee who is always chanting the holy names and then of course the last is someone who’s mere sight or presence inspires others to chant the holy name. So in the purport Srila Prabhupada mentions that one who has faith—again ādau śraddhā, everything depend on faith—one who has faith that the holy name of Krishna and Krishna are identical, is considered a pure devotee, even if he is in the neophyte position. He says that by chanting the holy name with that faith one realizes himself to be an eternal servant of the holy name and of the other servants of the holy name.
So when I—I don’t want to make it too particular about my situation but it is the principle and it is something we each can see how we can apply in our own situations—but when godbrothers come and I know they have taste for the holy name, so I think, “Oh, if I serve them,” because that is part of the process, if you serve someone, you develop their qualities. So I think, “Oh, Radhanath Swami is staying or Niranjana Swami is staying, Indradyumna Swami is staying. They have taste for the holy name. So if I serve them I will also by some mysterious process, I will also develop some taste for the holy name.”
And the holy name is a person. I remember—I guess I am easy influenced by the association—so when I first came into the day two days ago and was chanting, it was just flowing so easily. It was really fast. Mother Arcana Siddhi was just nearby and she chants very quick and I thought, “Wow! I could chant sixty-four rounds. I will be finished in no time!” [laughter] And then Sacinandana Swami came and sat behind me. I didn’t even turnaround. I didn’t even see you but I felt a change in the atmosphere. Every once in a while I would hear these long drawn out, “Hareee Krsnaaa, Hareee Krsnaaa,” and so then I also started—it wasn’t imitation but just absorbing that mood. So now I started also chanting slower and slower and I thought, “Wow, this is really nice,” really relishing then. But then after a while the thought came, “If I keep chanting at this rate, am I going to finish sixty-four rounds?” But then I thought, “Actually it is not the point to chant sixty-four rounds. The point is to associate with the holy name and please the holy name and if the holy name wants me to associate with Him or Them in this way then that is what I will do. What does it matter if I push down sixty-four.”
So now coming back to serving the servants of the holy name, this one time when Niranjana Swami was staying with me in Carpinteria, when I went to the beach in the evening to chant he asked me in quite a sincere way—but he is the type he doesn’t impose, he doesn’t put any demands on anyone. He is amazing. So even for him to ask in that very mild and gentle way was quite unusual for him and I marked—he said, “If it works and you are back in time I would like to speak with you.”
So I went to the beach and I was sitting and chanting and it was one of those times when it was flowing and it was like I didn’t want to stop. But at a certain stage I could see because the sun was starting to go down and I knew he was taking rest early and so I was in a dilemma because I was relishing, but at the same time I knew he wanted me to come back but he never asks for anything. And then I felt the holy name, I felt I got a message from the holy name that, “Niranjana Swami is very dear to Me. He is spreading the holy name all over the world. So if you go back and serve him, I will be pleased and whatever you miss from not chanting more now, I will make up to you later.” I don’t know if it was just a projection of my mind, but I took it that it was the holy name. So I came back.
So this is something else we can do, serve devotees who have a taste for the holy name and this again brings us back to full circle, the attachment for the spiritual master, then Nityananda Prabhu, Chaitanya Mahaprabhu, then Krishna. So it is the same with separation because the two go together. We feel separation from our spiritual master, we feel separation from advanced devotees who are in the category of sadhu, śikṣā-guru, and the way we can deal with our feelings of separation—of course we can hanker for their association—the other way is by serving their instructions, which Srila Prabhupada often said that by serving the instructions of the spiritual master you get his association. And Srila Prabhupada said, “I have been separated from my spiritual master for so many years, but by following his instructions I feel his presence.”
In the Fourth Canto of Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam in connection with the passing away of King Vidarbha, he had taken vanaprastha and he and his wife had gone into the forest and she had served him very faithfully. And then at a certain stage he left. She was lamenting piteously over his departure, the departure of the king who was her husband. Srila Prabhupada explains that the king figuratively is the spiritual master and the wife figuratively is the disciple. Just as the wife cried when her husband left, similarly the disciple should cry when the spiritual master leaves. Some of this I came across just after Prabhupada left and it was really instructive.
And then after some time a brahman appears to the queen and says, “I am your old friend. Don’t you remember me?” Srila Prabhupada explains that the old friend is actually Krishna, but he raises the question, why did Krishna come in the form of the brahman, why did He not come in His original form as Krishna. Srila Prabhupada gives the answer, he quotes quite extensively from Srila Visvanatha Cakravarti Thakura that unless one is very highly elevated in Krishna consciousness, one cannot see the Supreme Personality of Godhead directly face-to-face, but one can see the spiritual master by following his instructions. One can meet the spiritual master by following his instructions and that by following the instructions of the spiritual master, one ultimately sees Krishna, and instead of—again that idea of so-called devotees, sahajiyās—Prabhupada said instead of trying to see Krishna in some bush in Vrindavan, we should rather strictly adhere to the orders of the spiritual master and by following the orders of the spiritual master somehow we are in association with the spiritual master and Krishna.
First we have to associate. Just to summarize at the end, first we have to associate by vāṇī or vapuḥ. When we associate we develop attachment. And then when we have attachment, we can feel separation. And then when we feel separation we can chant with longing. And along with chanting with longing, we can make a very honest, earnest, and concerted endeavor to follow the instructions. And by following the instructions in that mood of longing and separation and part of the instructions are to chant and hear, chanting and hearing in the mood of longing for association, we come to closer to them. And coming closer to them means our attachment increases. And coming closer to them may mean, because there are so many different moods, it may mean feeling that we are with them, feeling their presence, or it may mean feeling their separation. But in any case it is association.
I am thinking of Rukmini devi dasi, she was the head pujari in the Boston temple when I was there, and she told me how from the very beginning she was always attracted to the Deities, but not always favorably, but she was always thinking of the Deities, but not always favorably. Sometimes she would have problems with Them or she would argue with Them or she would question Them, but she was always thinking about Them. And then gradually her relationship with Them became solidified and she became the head pujari.
So somehow or the other—yena tena prakāreṇa—-somehow or other fix the mind on Krishna, and Krishna is always there—whatever it is. Sometimes when we are in trouble we think of Krishna, “Oh Krishna, please save me.” And then when the trouble is over, “Oh, okay, we are all right. I don’t need Krishna. I did need Him but now I think I am okay. I can do without Him.” Some people are the opposite, if something good happens, “Oh, Krishna is there. Krishna really does love me. Krishna really does care for me.” And then if something bad happens, “Oh boy, I have been chanting, I have been serving, and this is what I get? What kind of God is this, what kind of process is this?”
So we link our material ups and downs or our Krishna consciousness is linked to our material ups and downs, but if we start to develop genuine spiritual attachment, then that prevails whatever the external upheavals are and then it doesn’t matter.
I will just conclude with one little excerpt from a talk that Srila Prabhupada gave. He was talking about the calamities that the Pandavas had to endure and it is described that when the Pandavas were in exile and having gone through so many terrible situations, Krishna came to them, and they weren’t expecting Him. He just appeared there and spontaneously they were filled with love for Krishna. They weren’t thinking, “Oh, You are our friend and look what happened to us.” They just felt love for Krishna. But Narada, he had that relationship with Krishna in which he could a little chide Him that, “The Pandavas are Your great devotees, Your surrendered souls, and they had to suffer so much. They were put in exile and their house was set on fire—just a whole litany of miseries. And they are Your devotees and they surrendered to You. Is that a very good way for You to deal with Your devotees?” Narada said, “But I don’t know what magic You work on Your devotees that even though so many calamities fall upon them, they are still mesmerized by Your transcendental name and form and qualities and pastimes and they still love You all the more. So I don’t know what hypnotism You work on Your devotees.”
So that should be our prayer. We should long to have that type of pure love for Krishna that, “No matter what happens—You may handle me tightly by Your embrace or make me brokenhearted by not being present before me—but You are my worshipful Lord unconditionally.”
Hare Krishna.
Dive into the Nectar
Books by Giriraj Swami

Dancing White Elephants
Traveling with Srila Prabhupada in India, August 1970-March 1972

I'll Build You a Temple
The epic story of challenge and triumph in the founding of the Juhu temple.

Watering the Seed
Anecdotes from the pastimes and teachings of Srila Prabhupada.

Many Moons
A recollection and celebration of the wonderful qualities, and activities of devotees who have left our vision

Life's Final Exam
Death and Dying from the Vedic Perspective
Deepen Your Spiritual Journey
Weekly Inspiration from Giriraj Swami
Sign up to receive weekly emails with exclusive content from Giriraj Swami, including recent lectures, excerpts from upcoming books, and announcements about workshops and retreats. Dive deeper into Krishna consciousness and stay connected with a community of like-minded seekers on your spiritual path.

