Avoiding The First Offense to the Holy Name
Zoom hosted by GRS Sanga
Giriraj Swami: Hare Krishna my dear devotees. Thank you for joining us for this important discussion. The first offense against the holy name is sādhu-nindā – to blaspheme devotees. And in order of avoid the offense of sādhu-nindā, it is necessary first to understand, who is the sadhu. So, we find many wonderful descriptions of qualities of devotees, sadhus in Bhagavad-gītā and Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam. But some of us may think that others are far from posing these qualities, so we are at liberty to criticize them but that is not the case. In his Harināma-cintāmaṇi, Srila Bhaktivinoda Thakura writes, “When a person attracted to the holy name, once says the holy name, his previous sins are destroyed. The scent of his previous sins may feel linger for some days but by the power of the holy name, they too gradually destroyed. The scent of sin is quickly eradicated. Then that person is known as great saint. During those days when the scent of the sin not yet is destroyed, to the ordinary eyes, he may see to be a sinner. But the critic of that person is an offender. Because he blasphemed the devotee, he commits the offense to the holy name, and Krishna will be angry with him.”
So, I will read about what Bhaktivinoda Thakura says about sadhu and sādhu-nindā.
READING from Harināma-cintāmaṇi
The first offense, known as sādhu-nindā, criticism of Vaishnavas, is very harmful for those wanting to progress in spiritual life. First let us define what sadhu or Vaishnava is. In the Eleventh Canto of the Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam, Kṛṣṇa enumerates to Uddhava the characteristics of a sadhu:
dayālu—merciful, sahiṣṇu—tolerant, sama—equal, droha-śūnya-vrata—penance without injury to the body, satya-sāra—truthfulness, viśuddhātmā—purified, parahita-rata—engaged in the welfare of mankind, kāme akṣubhita-buddhi—intelligence free from lust, danta—restrained, akiñcana—devoid of concept of ownership, mṛdu—gentle, śuci—clean, parimita-bhojī—regulated in eating and other habits, śāntamān—peaceful, anīha—apathy to materialism, dhṛimān—patience, sthira—steadiness, apramatta—attentive, alert, sugambhira—very grave, vijita-ṣaḍguṇa—conquering over the six gunas, (hunger, thirst, lamentation, envy, old age, and death), amānī—not expecting honor from others, mānada—giving respect to others, dakṣa—skillful, avāñcaka—nonhypocritical, jñānī—knowledgeable of the scriptures.
By these characteristics one can know who is a sadhu. However, here there are two types of characteristics: principal and marginal. The principal characteristic is exclusive surrender to Kṛṣṇa, while all others are dependent upon it. By some good fortune one may get the association of Vaishnavas, and then attain a taste for the name, chant the name and take shelter of Kṛṣṇa’s lotus feet. This becomes the chief characteristic, and by continuing to chant the name, all the other characteristics make their appearance. Therefore they are called marginal or accompanying. Though secondary to the principal characteristic, they will certainly appear in the body of a true Vaishnava or sadhu, as an effect of proper chanting of the holy name.
On the other hand, the status of grihastha, brahmacārī, vānaprastha and sannyāsī, śūdra, vaiśya, kṣatriya and brāhmaṇa of the varṇāśrama system, and their respective habits and qualities, are external distinctions which in no way determine who is a sadhu. The chief characteristic of a sadhu is his complete surrender to Kṛṣṇa, which is not dependent on a certain varṇa or āśrama.
Through the example of Raghunātha dāsa, Śrī Caitanya taught how the gṛhastha Vaiṣṇava should act. The married man should enter household life with a mind steadily fixed on service to Kṛṣṇa, not enamored by sense gratification, and in this way the householder can gradually cross the ocean of material existence. Instead of playing as a false renunciate (markaṭa vairāgī), enjoying with the senses in the cloth of a sannyāsī, it is better to take only those things necessary for survival in the material world, while cultivating nonattachment. One should always be internally fixed on Kṛṣṇa, though externally one may act according to one’s social custom in varṇa and āśrama. Kṛṣṇa quickly delivers such gṛhastha Vaiṣṇavas.
When Raghunātha dāsa gave up household life, the Lord gave him instruction on the life of renunciation:
“One should neither listen to materialistic conversations, nor speak materialistic topics to others. One should not eat fancy food, or wear fancy clothing. One should always chant the holy name, respecting all, without expecting honor, and meditate on eternal service to Rādhā and Kṛṣṇa in Vraja within one’s mind.”
“The principal characteristic is one, namely, surrender to Kṛṣṇa’s name, which will prevail in all sādhus, no matter what varṇa or āśrama, gṛhastha or sannyāsī. However, according to āśrama or varṇa, the secondary characteristics will differ to some degree. And even if there appears some bad element or fault in a person, if he has the chief characteristic, surrender to Kṛṣṇa, he must be considered a sādhu, and to be respected and served by all. This is Kṛṣṇa’s statement in Bhagavad-gītā.
COMMENT
So, we will just read a little more. It is a very interesting discussion but for the sake of time we won’t read Srila Bhaktivinoda Thakura’s full discussion of the topic.
READING (continued)
“When one has developed a taste for chanting the pure name, it is said that chanting just one time will destroy the influence of all past sins. Some remnants of those sins may still remain, but they will completely vanish by the influence of the holy name. Since these traces of sin will quickly go, that person is known as the most righteous person. Of course, if the materialist sees those traces of sin in a Vaiṣṇava sādhu, he may consider that the sādhu is just like a materialistic sinner. If he should criticize the sādhu because the sādhu has a trace of sin coming from previous sinful activity, he is committing sādhu-nindā. He is to be considered a rascal because of his fault of criticizing a Vaiṣṇava; and by this nāma-aparādha (offense unto one who has surrender to the name) he falls directly under the wrath of Kṛṣṇa.
“It is concluded that one who is solely devoted to Kṛṣṇa and sings His name is known as a sādhu. Other than the devotees of Kṛṣṇa, no one else is considered to be a sādhu. One who considers himself a sādhu is filled with material pride. But one who thinks himself to be the lowest rascal, humbly takes shelter of Kṛṣṇa and sings Kṛṣṇa’s name, is the real sādhu. Knowing himself to be less than a blade of grass, considering himself like a tree of tolerance, not expecting honor for himself and giving honor to all other living entities, he chants the name and attains attraction for Kṛṣṇa.
“If a person of the above qualities chants the holy name even once, he is considered a Vaiṣṇava, and should be respected. The Vaiṣṇava is the friend and spiritual leader of the universe; he is an ocean of mercy to all living entities. Whoever criticizes such a Vaiṣṇava goes to hell birth after birth; for there is no path for real liberation other than bhakti, and bhakti is obtained only by the mercy of the Vaiṣṇavas.
“In the pure Vaiṣṇava resides Kṛṣṇa’s energies of bhakti, hlādinī and samvit. Thus by contacting a Vaiṣṇava one can also receive Kṛṣṇa bhakti. For this reason also, the food remnants, the foot water and the foot dust from the pure Vaiṣṇavas are three powerful articles for creating bhakti. If one stays near a pure Vaiṣṇava for some time, one can receive the bhakti energy flowing from his body. If one can bind that energy within one’s heart, after having developed strong faith, bhakti will develop and one’s body will begin to tremble in ecstasy. Thus, by living close to a Vaiṣṇava, soon devotion will appear in one’s heart. First, such a person will begin chanting the holy name, and then, by the power of the name, he will receive all good qualities. This is the particular power of the uttama adhikārī.
“A Vaiṣṇava may be criticized on four counts: his caste by birth, previous sins or faults in this life, an unpremeditated accidental act of sin, and present traces of previous sinful activity. Though all these conditions may be present in a Vaiṣṇava, they are insubstantial grounds for criticism of a Vaiṣṇava. One who so blasphemes a Vaiṣṇava will be punished by Yamarāja. Because the Vaiṣṇava is spreading the glories of the Lord’s name, the Lord does not tolerate such criticism of a Vaiṣṇava. Giving up dharma, yoga, sacrifice and jñāna for the name of Kṛṣṇa, the Vaiṣṇava is the topmost person. Criticism is a serious offense. Furthermore he does not criticize the scriptures or the demigods, but simply takes shelter of the name.
COMMENT
And a nice example is given that when one is walking barefoot in the hot sun, one feels the pain of the heat more on one’s feet rather than on one’s head. So, in the same way, Krishna feels criticism of His devotees who have taken shelter of His lotus feet more acutely. He takes it more seriously than criticism of Himself.
READING (continued)
“It goes without saying that one who has taken shelter of the name will not indulge in sādhu-nindā. One who criticizes a sādhu is not situated in bhakti, but in aparādha against bhakti.
COMMENT
And this word we know the word aparādha means offense and some devotees have explained aparādha to mean against Radha, aparādha
READING (continued)
A serious person therefore would not indulge in criticism, but associate with, hear from and serve the sādhu.
COMMENT
Now, the next is a very important point my dear devotees.
READING (continued)
“Because association with those who are not devotees is bound to produce disrespect for devotees (sādhu-nindā), the devotee is careful to avoid such association.
COMMENT
And here Srila Bhaktivinoda Thakura quotes from Sri Chaitanya Mahaprabhu in Śrī Caitanya-caritāmṛta. asat-saṅga-tyāga, one should avoid the association asat, asat-saṅga-tyāga — ei vaiṣṇava-ācāra – that is the behavior of Vaishnava. ‘strī-saṅgī’ — eka asādhu, ‘kṛṣṇābhakta’ ārao. So ‘strī-saṅgī’ means one who is attached to women for sense gratification even if the person is a devotee, and ‘kṛṣṇābhakta’ ārao, and one who is not a devotee.
READING (continued)
“The second type of asat association, association with nondevotees, is of three types: association with māyāvādīs, association with pretenders, and association with atheists.”
COMMENT
And then Srila Bhaktivinoda Thakura describes these different categories. And again, the idea is that by associating with these types of people, you could say non devotees, one becomes prone to engage in sādhu-nindā. So to protect ourselves from sādhu-nindā, we should associate with devotees who themselves are free from sādhu-nindā. So there is so much more, but we also want to have time for discussion. So I will end this preliminary discussion of the topic and we will open the floor for discussion. Hare Krishna.
Host: Wonderful. Thank you, Maharaja, for so perfectly giving us context to how to approach this topic. And one thing you said that was so important and actually connects to the first question that we have. You were saying when a person chants even once, the holy name, all of his previous sin is destroyed but a scent of the previous sin might linger. And that was some connected to something Srila Prabhupada also said in a letter to Vrinda devi, saying, we should always keep in mind that we are recruiting members from people in general. So they might not automatically right away adhere to the highest standard but it is a work in progress. Jaya Advaita Maharaja once said, do we ever think ‘Oh I am too sick to go to the hospital.’ So the first question would be whenever we encounter these behaviors that are a scent of a sin from a fellow devotee, how can we develop this understanding and compassion in such situations and crucially then how do we translate this understanding into our actions and interactions with the devotees so as to not commit further offenses?
Giriraj Swami: Well, one of the twenty-six qualities of a devotee is sympathetic. So, we should be sympathetic to people in general and to devotees in particular. And if a devotee is having some difficulty, we should be compassionate. And we should as far as possibly try to help the devotee overcome his or her challenges. Srila Prabhupada said that if a devotee is having difficulty and we think ‘Oh that devotee is in maya; I don’t want to associate that devotee.’ That is the mundane attitude. And if we think ‘Oh that devotee is having difficulty, let me help that devotee.’ That is the Vaikuntha attitude.
Host: That is wonderful. And well, along that topic of wanting to help others, sometimes when you are in a position whoever is in a position of authority or leadership, they might have to tell a devotee something in the light of constructive criticism. But often times our ego is so intertwined with everything that, one might get defensive right whenever someone tells us something or a correction even if it is trying to benefit us, we have this tendency to get a little defensive. So could you give some advice on how to not get defensive and close our hearts up whenever someone is trying to give us guidance, coming from a good place. And I guess on the flip side, how to also give constructive criticism in a way that someone can more openly receive it. So from both ends—how to give it constructively and how to receive it without getting defensive.
Giriraj Swami: Well, Srila Prabhupada said that if criticism is offered with sympathy, it is more likely to be accepted. So, we should offer the criticism or correction in a sympathetic mood, wanting to help the devotee and not show that we are superior; rule over the devotee. And if someone is correcting us, we should be grateful that ‘Oh this person is trying to help me. This person cares for me and is making the effort to help me.’ Once, His Holiness Nava Yogendra Swami serving the Srila Prabhupada, serving in Juhu in 1977. And He made a mistake. And Srila Prabhupada chastised him. And His Holiness Nava Yogendra Swami said, “Srila Prabhupada, when you chastise us, we don’t know what to do. We don’t know what to think or what to feel?” And Srila Prabhupada said, “You should feel blissful. So many people walking down the street. They have no one who cares for them; who will take the trouble to correct them. So you should feel happy that you have someone who cares for you and is ready to correct you as required.”
Host: And like you said, it is so important, the mood that we say it and with compassion. That is why I think Maharaja whenever you say something to anybody, we can receive it so openly because you say it so sweetly and you can really feel the care there. And a quick reminder to all the devotees that, please when you have any questions, pop up for you, you can submit them in the chat. We have Avadarya so graciously looking through them, so we can bring up some more questions. We have an interesting one here that talks about within the context of the six types of offenses to devotees. The first one to blaspheme Vaishnava. They were saying the third, fourth, and fifth offense which is to not feel delighted upon seeing Vaishnava, to think ill of Vaishnava, and to get angry with Vaishnava. Those all seem that they might potentially manifest solely in our minds. So, I guess on one hand, they are wondering, are these mental offenses as have as much weight as when we commit a physical offense? And if so, how can we genuinely avoid having these mental offenses. Sometimes, it is hard to control our thoughts or if we are a little unhappy, not delighted to see a Vaishnava, it might be this whole internal world we are experiencing. So how to avoid that?
Giriraj Swami: Well, Vaishnavas are rare and precious. And if we associate only with Vaishnavas we might take them for granted. When we go out, for example, for book distribution and we see what kind of people are out there, when we come back, we can really appreciate the value of devotees. Be happy in their company.
Host: That is so true.
Giriraj Swami: Yes, So I think it is healthy in both ways if we go out and meet people who are not devotees and try to give them Krishna consciousness in one form or another. That is good because we are showing mercy. And it is also good because it will bring us to appreciate devotees more, and we see the contrast.
Host: That is so True. Kala Chandji Prabhu who was recently here was saying that his wife is a teacher; I am a teacher and they are lovely people but there is something special about devotees that you they look at you with such love and they have such humility, so it is something special. So another question actually by our own Avadarya. She was saying, we speak so often about offending devotees but how can we really cultivate the maturity to not take offense and to be able to receive things in a way that we don’t so easily get offended?
Giriraj Swami: Once Srila Prabhupada criticized me by letter. Let me see if I can find it. I think I can.
Host: What a treat. We are going to hear a letter from Srila Prabhupada.
Giriraj Swami: Alright, so this is what he wrote. “I have got some reports that the deities in Bombay are being very much neglected. This is a most abominable affair. Rada and Krishna should not ever be neglected or left unprotected. So, I am wondering what you have done to rectify the situation.” So, it was a very heavy letter. “This is the most abominable affair.” But still like I formulated a reply. And in the reply, I mentioned I am trying to maintain my enthusiasm. He wrote back explaining his motive in his chastisement. Basically he wrote that “My only concern is that you and all my other disciples make progress in Krishna consciousness. So if you find some criticism, kindly take it in that spirit.”
Host: That makes me think, see because I studied interpersonal communication. So if I feel heard or have a problem with someone I like to go directly to the person to talk about it, and it made me think how Keshava Swami talks about our ability to go within, when we are chanting for example is so dependent on our ability to mediate our external relationships because if that is a mess, our external world going within might be a little more difficult. So your story of how well you took Srila Prabhupada’s advice. How have you in your life navigated difficult situations that let’s say someone says something to you in a way that might be a little hurtful or whatever might come up that one might easily slip into criticism. How have you yourself over time to deal with these situations that inevitably come up in a healthy way.
Giriraj Swami: Well, to be perfectly honest, I would consider what is the motive of the person who is doing the criticism. If they want to help me do better, well and good. I am happy to receive that advice. And we hope that is the case. But sometimes, the criticism might not be justified and I would evaluate it to see if it is justified or not. Not because I am defensive or my false ego is reacting but just to consider whether it is a valid criticism or not. I think of sort of a joke on the side, but I think of what His Holiness Ṛtadhvaja Swami once said, “I only made one mistake in my life. Once I thought I was wrong and I wasn’t.” [laughter]
Host: I can totally picture Ṛtadhvaja Maharaja saying that. Yes. So okay, you are using your power to decipher, does this person really have my best intention or not. Now, let us say the person might not have your best intention at their heart. This connects to a few questions around this theme of how can we nurture the capacity and readiness to forgive someone even when we ourselves feel really hurt or offended. Maybe someone didn’t treat us well, they didn’t have the best intention in mind. So how can we not carry that resentment in our heart and try to let it go, so practicing forgive. How would we go about doing that?
Giriraj Swami: Yes. forgiveness is very important. Not only for the person who we are forgiving but also for ourselves. And I will read a little about forgiveness because it is a very important topic. So, forgiveness defines and beautifies a brahman. And then there are two quotes from Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam that substantiate this point. I will skip the Sanskrit for the sake of time but I will read the translations.
“My dear son, we are all brāhmaṇas and have become worshipable for the people in general because of our quality of forgiveness. It is because of this quality that Lord Brahmā, the supreme spiritual master of this universe, has achieved his post.”
“The duty of a brāhmaṇa is to culture the quality of forgiveness, which is illuminating like the sun. The Supreme Personality of Godhead, Hari, is pleased with those who are forgiving.” (Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 9.15.39 and 40.)
And in the purport Srila Prabhupada explains,
“Different personalities become beautiful by possessing different qualities. Cāṇakya Paṇḍita says that the cuckoo bird, although very black, is beautiful because of its sweet voice. Similarly, a woman becomes beautiful by her chastity and faithfulness to her husband, and an ugly person becomes beautiful when he becomes a learned scholar. In the same way, brāhmaṇas, kṣatriyas, vaiśyas, and śūdras become beautiful by their qualities. Brāhmaṇas are beautiful when they are forgiving.”
So it is very important both for the person we forgive and for ourselves, to forgive them and not harbor any grudge.
Host: It is so true how you say for ourselves, because if not, it becomes like a weight or poison that we are just carrying around with us. And in a similar thread, what would you say about, okay, if we are offended, what is a good way to go about sharing grievances or our pain with society, with each other, if at all can this be done in a healthy way? To air out our frustrations?
Giriraj Swami: Yes. Sometimes it is not good to keep things inside because then they just brew and fester and become worse. So it is often good to share our frustration or disappointment or hurt with someone else. But we should try to do it in such a way that we don’t blaspheme the person who hurt us. But we just present it to our friend or our confidant that this person said this or this person did this, and I felt hurt by it and I don’t want to feel hurt.
Host: Right. It is so important what you are highlighting; our intention in how we approach devotees with our constructive criticism, how we approach trying to air out our hurt or our grievances. It is all about where our heart is and I am thinking, how did Srila Prabhupada react or respond if devotees who had negative behavior or disposition? How did he respond to them so that we may learn from his example? Do you have any examples of your association with him?
Giriraj Swami: How did he respond to what?
Host: One person is wondering, how did react or respond to if a devotee had a negative behavior or did something that was hurtful whether it is to our own selves or to others, how did he respond to negative behavior?
Giriraj Swami: It would depend on the individual and the situation. It said that we have to choose our battles. Sometimes, the devotee may make a mistake, faith that by their continuing in the process of bhakti-yoga, they will eventually improve. In the Bhagavad-gītā also Krishna says,
api cet su-durācāro
bhajate mām ananya-bhāk
sādhur eva sa mantavyaḥ
samyag vyavasito hi saḥ
That even if one engages in the most abominable activity, if he is properly situated in devotional service, still he is considered saintly, sādhur eva sa mantavyaḥ. So, it may be like that; that we just give the devotee time and Krishna within the heart will help the devotee to rectify because the devotee is engaged in bhakti-yoga. But then again, sometimes as Srila Prabhupada showed, sometimes we have to point out the fault. Although, once did say that, the one thing he didn’t like about being the spiritual master is that he would have to correct devotees and they are all Vaishnavas. He actually said that. Because it was part of his duty.
Host: Right, so at that level, he didn’t want to have to see the faults but his role called for that. Thinking of that topic, sometimes we hear, we I think there was a famous lecture Srila Prabhupada gave that you can call a spade a spade. And later on Jaya Advaita Maharaja give another lecture that stood out where he was saying, there are no spades, don’t criticize the Vaishnava. So, how would we merge those two statements of call a spade, a spade but at the same time, there are no spades. How would you make sense of that?
Giriraj Swami: Yes. Again, it depends on the circumstances. Srila Bhaktivinoda Thakura has spoken very strongly that we should not talk about others. In fact, once I gave a talk on this topic in Alachua. And one of the members in the audience quoted a saying that she heard from her father which is, “There is so much good in the worst of us. And so much bad in the best of us. It hardly behooves any of us to speak about the rest of us.”
Host: Oh, I like that.
Giriraj Swami: Yes, so Srila Bhaktivinoda Thakura, after many strong statements that we should not speak about others. He did add some qualifiers. And he said that we may have to speak about others for the sake of warning innocent devotees. About the negative influence that the other person could have. Not with any malice but just out of concern to protect an innocent person, not because one enjoys talking about others faults.
Host: Right. Now that actually so perfectly connects to one of the questions a devotee is asking. New, young, maybe innocent devotees might err on the side of caution and never criticize, anyone think ‘All Vaishnavas are absolutely perfect.’ But in such a mood, that might result in that newer devotee being either taken advantage of or exploited by some personality, who maybe a little more calculating and ambitious. So, how would you guide a devotee to follow their common-sense, part of which means they have to rely on old categories of seeing the world and categorizing it, judging it a little bit while one is also trying to let go of judging? How would you advise someone how to navigate those currents?
Giriraj Swami: Srila Prabhupada said, if someone takes advantage of us and we don’t lose then we don’t mind. Like during the first Delhi pandal, a lot of politicians would come on the stage and praise Srila Prabhupada and ISKCON. And one of the devotees said to Srila Prabhupada that, “They are praising you and ISKCON but their politicians. And basically, they just want to win the favor of people because we are getting like twenty thousand people every day, they just want to get the votes of the of the people who are in the pandal program.” And Srila Prabhupada said, “If someone takes advantage of us and we don’t lose from it, we don’t mind.”
Host: Right. Then I guess just using your intelligence to see. “Am I being hurt by this or really, it is something I can let slide.” Would you be able to elaborate a little on how understanding our own limitations, might contribute to fostering respect and reverence for everyone that is necessary to avoid criticizing them. Because sometimes when we criticize, we are really not even looking at ourselves, we are just so quick to look at everyone else. So, how can that mood of understanding our own limitations and being honest with ourselves help with this whole topic of not being defensive?
Giriraj Swami: Yes, basically what you are saying is that if we are aware of our own faults, we will be humble. And then if we are humble, we won’t find fault with others or blaspheme others.
So I just thought of something relevant on this point of sādhu-nindā. Srila Bhaktivinoda Thakura says that if someone criticizes someone who is not a sadhu, thinking that he is criticizing a sadhu that he is engaging in a sādhu-nindā. Then that person is engaged in sādhu-nindā. And we had the example of Srila Prabhupada and Dr. Patel on their morning walks. And one time, Srila Prabhupada criticized someone who Dr. Patel thought was a sadhu, who Srila Prabhupada didn’t think was a sadhu. And Dr. Patel became really upset. And for a few days, he is actually stopped coming on the walks. He would always come every morning for the walk, but was so upset, he stopped coming for a few days. And then as he describes it one day, he was walking on the beach but not with Prabhupada. And then he saw Prabhupada, he said, something in his heart just impelled him to go to Srila Prabhupada and touch his feet. And then he said to Srila Prabhupada, “We have been taught to respect all the accredited saints in India. Srila Prabhupada replied, “Yes, and our business is to point out who is a saint and who is not a saint.”
Host: That is funny. Yes, he had that position because he was setting the example for so many of us. So, what to follow, what not to follow. With this whole topic of the first offense, which is known to be the most serious of all offenses, why do you think that is so? Why is it the most serious of all the offenses?
Giriraj Swami: Oh yes, because Krishna, like I mentioned, He feels more pain when a devotee who has taken shelter his lotus feet is blasphemed than when he himself is blasphemed.
Host: Right. That could be the answer to someone else had asked, “What qualities of Krishna make blaspheming the devotees such a horrendous act. So, that would show that Krishna has such compassion like they often say a mother feels more painful when her children suffer than her own. So, I guess that would answer the other devotee’s question about we have such a compassionate Lord. That would probably be why, I suppose, it is such an offense. You had said something in LA Ratha-yatra recently connected to this topic that I really liked about maintaining good relations with devotees and how that is connected to our desires. Because we are all in this material world struggling with so many desires and trying to get rid of them. So, would you be able to recall what you had said at that Q&A, of why maintaining good relations with devotees is so important and how that is connected to our desires?
Giriraj Swami: The context was Srila Prabhupada said that if one wants to remain brahmachari, one should maintain good relations with others. And I considered what is the connection between the two. And I thought of two things. One is that to maintain good relations with others, we have to be in the mode of goodness. And to remain brahmachari, we have to be in the mode of goodness. And the other I thought is that, if we don’t maintain good relations with others, in other words, if we commit offenses against others and the result of committing offenses, one of the results of committing offenses is that one is afflicted by material desires, which could lead the brahmachari to fall down from his position of being a brahmachari.
Host: Right. So while they are directly connected, good relations help lower desires, offending devotees, increases desires. And how would then sādhu-nindā interfere also with our chanting? Because sometimes we might think it is not linked to how we chant the holy name or the results we are getting from chanting, but would you be able to explain a little, how it is actually related?
Giriraj Swami: The holy name is Krishna. Krishna will reveal Himself to us or He will be pleased to manifest Himself to us, when He is pleased with our service.
ataḥ śrī-kṛṣṇa-nāmādi
na bhaved grāhyam indriyaiḥ
sevonmukhe hi jihvādau
svayam eva sphuraty adaḥ
So, Krishna will be pleased with us when He sees that we are appreciating His devotees, and He will be displeased with us when He sees that we are disrespecting His devotees or blaspheming His devotees, and so He won’t reveal Himself to us in the form of His holy name.
Host: And on the topic of criticizing devotees, we have a live question from the chat that was saying, “We have a lot of grihastha couples who are exclusively surrendered to Krishna. But then they are always criticizing each other and arguing, but they do stay together no matter what. So are arguments and criticisms between couples considered vaiṣṇava-aparādha?”
Giriraj Swami: Well, I would suggest that the husband and wife do try to see each other as Vaishnavas and respect each other as Vaishnavas because they are. But then again Srila Prabhupada said quarrels between husband and wife should not be taken very seriously. But it is very healthy for them individually and also as a couple to see each other as Vaishnavas and respect each other as Vaishnavas, and serve each other as Vaishnavas. That would make for a very beautiful relationship.
Host: That is so true because over time we might get content with someone complacent and that breeds so many. We stop respecting them in the way we normally would respect someone. So still seeing them as a Vaishnava is a very good golden rule to refer to. And another question someone had is, in our day-to-day work life, we may have to deal with many non-devotees. So, they ask, how can we avoid that association to avoid first offense due to association of non-devotees. But I would ask you I guess, whenever you interact with non-devotees, would you try to avoid them so you don’t slip into committing any offenses? Or how to have a good frame of mind when approaching non-devotees, maybe would be a good place to start?
Giriraj Swami: Srila Bhaktivinoda Thakura also discusses this point. He says that in our workplace or in our educational institution we will naturally have to associate with non-devotees. And he says that we should be polite and respectful, but we should not take their advice on spiritual matters.
Host: And I think you are such an example Maharaja of whenever you go about in the world. You are on your japa walk by the ocean, everyone passing by, you greet everybody. “Hello. How are you? Hello.” So, you are such an example of just developing friendships. And wasn’t it Tamal Krishna Goswami who said it, all starts with being friends with someone. And when he was in SMU also, he didn’t try to preach. He just went to connect with his professors and through that friendship, he was able to reach their hearts in much deeper ways than if he just tried to preach right off the bat. So I think you so beautifully embody that with relationships with people who aren’t necessarily on the path of bhakti.
Giriraj Swami: Yes. And one of the qualities of a devotee is friendly.
Host: We have another question that says, ”I want to get rid of offenses. My father does not support bhakti and blasphemes the devotees and Srila Prabhupada. But by my bad fortune, I have heard all these things. So now, when I see devotees, those things come to mind and I too blasphemes. So please help me to stop so that I can chant.” So, I guess yes, when we are surrounded by, I think many people have situations where their families, close friends are unfavorable and they might say things that get in our heads. So, how to combat that and not get swayed by the opinions of people who are close to us?
Giriraj Swami: Well, His Holiness Ṛtadhvaja Swami made a deal with his mother that he wouldn’t try to convert her into becoming a devotee if she didn’t criticize devotees. So they came to a truce.
Host: Right. They made a deal. I remember Ṛtadhvaja Maharaja talking about that to me, once saying that, so he would do his things more subtly before she would eat in his mind, he would be quickly offer the prasādam so that without her knowing, she would be eating prasādam. But they tried to accommodate for each other’s needs. But what about for a devotee that really, they are impressionable and the things people who are close to them what they say really influences them, so in this devotee’s question about his father blaspheming devotees and now he or she too has begun to do that. What advice would you give to such a devotee to not let it influence them so much?
Giriraj Swami: Well, as Krishna says in the Bhagavad-gītā that we have to control the mind with the intelligence. So the mind might be affected by hearing blasphemy but with our intelligence, we know that it is harmful for us to blaspheme devotees and we should control our mind with our intelligence, and not blaspheme devotees.
Host: Right. So how would you navigate another question someone’s asking, sometimes we are not trying to offend a senior devotee but we are not able to understand or fully agree with what they are saying. Maybe due to our lack of qualification or our way of thinking is different. So how do we navigate such scenarios without feeling like we are offending? And also, in what scenarios can such situations become offensive? So I guess what is the fine line of disagreeing but not being offensive and they are wondering advice with navigating that.
Giriraj Swami: While disagreeing with a more senior devotee is allowed and I think of one example that Srila Prabhupada gave about driving in a car. The driver is taking a certain route to reach a destination. The passenger thinks that he or she knows a better route. So the passenger can present that to the driver. It is not offensive at all. It is just a suggestion how to reach the destination; a better way. But then Srila Prabhupada said, but ultimately the driver is in the driver’s seat and so the driver will decide. But he also said that even though the driver may not accept the advice of the passenger, the passenger might still maintain the idea that his or her way was better. That is allowed.
Host: Right. I guess, you can still treat them with respect and then just continue doing what you might think is the best if it is not detrimental to anybody. The next question is interesting. And it has two parts and maybe you can shed some light on it. The Bhagavad-gītā says, even if one commits the most abominable action, if he is engaged in devotional service, he is to be considered saintly because he is properly situated in his determination. But the person is asking, such abominable actions they may really hurt and offend someone and to the detriment of their physical, emotional, or spiritual well-being. So they are asking, what is Krishna really saying here? I think it might be hard to think of someone as a saintly person if they do really horrible horrible, they are saying abominable actions, so the mind goes to what is the worst thing someone could possibly do. And are we supposed to still see that individual as a saintly person. In a practical way that seems very difficult to do.
Giriraj Swami: I think abominable means in a personal sense, it doesn’t refer to offending devotees or hurting devotees. I would say that is in a different category. But still you can still consider them saintly if they are properly situated in devotional service.
Host: So right, you are saying there is different categories so it might not here refer to the most extreme abominable act we might think of murder or something horrible. It might not necessarily refer to those. Okay I see. And the second part of the question they are asking, the accidental fall down of a devotee from the path of saintly character does not make him abominable, they are quoting. So how do we define accidental? Are there some actions that are accidental versus I guess they are maybe thinking what is an abominable act like murder or other horrible things is that truly accidental? So, they are trying to understand what would be an accidental fall down, because some actions seem not accidental so that how can we go about understanding that and still seeing that devotee in a saintly light?
Giriraj Swami: Yes, murder, that is a completely difference category. But accidental means not premeditated but just by force of past habit or maybe a bad association, one falls down, but then one should regret and repent. And Srila Prabhupada said that repentance is also a type of purification. And resolve not to make the same mistake again. It can happen.
Host: What advice would you give to a new devotee, who might not fully understand what a Vaishnava is doing. They don’t know how to interpret something. How would you advise them in those cases to not commit offenses if they don’t fully understand the actions of a devotee?
Giriraj Swami: Well, they should be humble. A very important part of all of these activities is being humble. Someone is a new devotee; of course, sometimes new devotees are less humble. They should realize that they are new. There are many things they don’t know or understand. And yes, they should be respectful of the more senior devotees.
Host: Right. Yes, when I look at someone like you Maharaja, I think you have been here for so many decades, gone through so much and done so much incredible service for Srila Prabhupada that you have probably also come into contact with all sorts of personalities and different types of people in your time serving Srila Prabhupada in the movement. We have been talking about this whole topic now of blaspheming a Vaishnava, humility, different themes. Do you have any little anecdotes that come to mind of times that you felt like, okay Krishna’s really testing you or pushing your limits where it was a real learning curve things along, something along this topic that I am sure you have had so many different types of encounters with different personalities? So, it is always nice to hear the personal side, so do you have any that come to mind that you feel could be relevant to share under this topic throughout your years of service?
Giriraj Swami: Well, in Juhu, we did have some devotees were difficult to deal with. But we knew Srila Prabhupada wanted us to engage them. And he said, you should learn the art like how to bend someone without breaking them.
Host: How to bend someone without breaking them. Right.
Giriraj Swami: Srila Prabhupada hadn’t made this famous statement that, “Your love for me will be shown by how you cooperate,” at that stage but we knew that that was what Srila Prabhupada wanted. He wanted us to cooperate and so for the sake of Srila Prabhupada, we would do it. We would work with people. Otherwise, we wouldn’t have particularly wanted to work with for the higher cause.
Host: That is a good point that you always kept in mind what is the essence of what I am doing is for a higher cause. So, nothing is going to get in the way. So like a horse with blinders, you were focused on your mission for Srila Prabhupada and other things became irrelevant I suppose. You found a way to navigate them to deal with the people as you said to bend them without breaking them. Well, on the topic of your travels with Srila Prabhupada, we know that you have a book, The Dancing White Elephant. So would you be able to mention a few words about the book and afterwards Krishna Kirtan Prabhu, he is going to say, how we can find it in all of those details. But could you give us a little a few words on that?
Giriraj Swami: Yes, the book is called Dancing White Elephants, and it is taken from a phrase that Srila Prabhupada himself used to describe his disciples. And it covers traveling with Srila Prabhupada. Let me just check the dates. Dancing White Elephants—Travelling With Srila Prabhupada in India, August 1970 to March 1972. So, it begins from pretty much when we first arrived in India up until we got the Juhu land. So we had “Dancing White Elephants—Travelling With Srila Prabhupada in India, August 1970 to March 1972.
Host: Wow, that will be so many adventures in there. I am looking forward to reading that. And Maharaja, what I thought, we just finished going through so many different questions on so many different topics. And I feel like a very simple way to answer all of them is what would Giriraj Swami do. We look at you as when we have all these questions about, how to navigate devoted relations? Can we criticize should we not? You are someone that shows such humility and grace and compassion in the face of no matter who you are in acting with, you just maintain your soft heart and so sweet. So, whether you are giving an instruction, a correction or saying something kind, people can receive it so openly. So, I feel what would Giriraj Swami do as the conclusion and the answer to all the questions we just covered?
Thank you so so much Maharaja for your time and for so beautifully and thoughtfully answering all of these questions. Would you be able to guide us in Vaishnava praṇāma and then Krishna Kirtan or Krishna Kirtan Prabhu, would you first like to say about the book and then we do.
Okay wonderful.
Krishna Kirtan Prabhu: So. we heard in the beginning of this Zoom podcast that guru Maharaja read about the different qualities of a sadhu and one of them, guru Maharaja said that a sadhu is one who is engaged in the welfare of mankind. So, I took that one way that we can engage in the welfare of mankind is by giving people Krishna consciousness. And the practical way of doing that is to give them to the Prabhupada’s books. So in the same we request you to distribute The Dancing White Elephant when it comes out. We have created a website for the new book. It is called “ancingwhitewlephants.com. We would like you to do couple of things and this is very important. One is to pre-order the book. There is a pre-order form on this website. So distribute the website link to people and have them pre-order. Most importantly, order bookcase like one box at a time with some discount that you can get and distribute those books after you order them. We also want you to encourage and advertise this website to your temples and local centers because often times they don’t know that the book is coming out or is out. So that is very important and also want you to share this website in your social media page on Instagram, Facebook, or any other social media account you have. And also guru Maharaja is going to be travelling, wherever he is having a program if you can have a book table or whenever you have a program in your house or temple., ask permission and have a book table of guru Maharaja’s books and we can promote Dancing White Elephants that way.
So thank you for helping and distributing this very important book. Guru Maharaja took a lot of effort to write this book. Let us do our part by reading them and reading the book and distributing them. Yes, thank you so much. So guru Maharaja, we would like to humbly request you to take us to Vaishnava praṇāma to end this session today.
Hare Krishna.
Let us offer our respectful obeisances unto all the Vaishnava devotees of the Lord. They are just like desire trees who can fulfill the desires of everyone, and they are full of compassion for the fallen conditioned souls.
vāñchā-kalpatarubhyaś ca kṛpā-sindhubhya eva ca
patitānāṁ pāvanebhyo vaiṣṇavebhyo namo namaḥ
Dive into the Nectar
Books by Giriraj Swami

Dancing White Elephants
Traveling with Srila Prabhupada in India, August 1970-March 1972

I'll Build You a Temple
The epic story of challenge and triumph in the founding of the Juhu temple.

Watering the Seed
Anecdotes from the pastimes and teachings of Srila Prabhupada.

Many Moons
A recollection and celebration of the wonderful qualities, and activities of devotees who have left our vision

Life's Final Exam
Death and Dying from the Vedic Perspective
Deepen Your Spiritual Journey
Weekly Inspiration from Giriraj Swami
Sign up to receive weekly emails with exclusive content from Giriraj Swami, including recent lectures, excerpts from upcoming books, and announcements about workshops and retreats. Dive deeper into Krishna consciousness and stay connected with a community of like-minded seekers on your spiritual path.

